4 ms·
I didn't see any emergent behavior, just combining of skills (which I'll admit looks useful). Calling this emergent is click bait.
by fooqux 9mo ago
I didn't see any emergent behavior, just combining of skills (which I'll admit looks useful). Calling this emergent is click bait.
- ryanthedev 9mo agoyou're not wrong. my goal was for more playful.
- furyofantares 9mo agoWell, it's a little odd, because up until a couple months ago we had to have everything we wanted it to be able to do in context anyway.
- oooyay 9mo agoYeah, after reading this I was thinking, "how is this different from agents using a combination of tools, resources, and prompts?" They do surprising things sometimes but it's not particularly novel of Claude Code.
- ryanthedev 9mo agoi see it as skills being logical grouping of a set of prompts, which achieve a goal. Like my optimize-critical-path skill. It's more than a single prompt, but less than an entire agent. I find skills to be the tools you use on the fly. Like how I might have a wrench,screw-driver, hammer in my tool box. tools vs skills is all about context efficiency from what I see. and yes, this isn't novel of claude. but they are the first to offer this abstraction.
- oooyay 9mo ago> they are the first to offer this abstraction. My point is that Skills are not the first to do this. Well written MCPs are dynamic workflow engines. Skills are like a more user focused and slimmed down version of MCPs. It'd be interesting to see a comparison of a well written MCP compared to a skill in terms of task competency.
- ryanthedev 9mo agoAhhhh. I see now. Now that you mention it, i can see a future where claude may offer a "skills" feature and codex offers a "talent" feature. where they are essentially the same things, but specific to that vendor. reminds me how each cloud has the same offerings but different products.
- joshuacc 9mo agoCodex added skills support recently. It appears to work exactly the same as Claude Code.
- ryanthedev 9mo agoohhh! I'm gonna have to try that out. Thankfully everybody is still playing nice hahah!
- joshribakoff 9mo agoYeah, it’s literally talked about and documented by the vendor as an intended characteristic of the design.