5 ms·
> "I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it." - Voltaire Wouldn't you then likewise defend the right of people to
by _delirium 14y ago
> "I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it." - Voltaire
Wouldn't you then likewise defend the right of people to criticize the post, including to criticize it harshly, even if you disagree with he criticisms or the way they're phrased?
edit: That said, I can see a case for communities maintaining discourse norms, in order to promote discussion/etc. But to me that's precisely the opposite of a free-speech absolutist view, because discourse norms are limits on what/how/when to say things.
- waratuman 14y agoPeople did not criticize the post but the person.
- dmix 14y agoFree speech still applies even if it's offending another person.
- zaptheimpaler 14y agoNo, thats defamation/libel, and it is a civil offense, even a criminal offense in some cases. Free speech is not an unconditional right, it places responsibilities on those who exercise it.
- dmix 14y agoDefamation laws are one of those laws that skirt on a thin-line of interfering with free speech rights (similar to hate crime laws). It's also not simply offending language that equals defamation. From wikipedia: "Opinion is a defence recognized in nearly every jurisdiction. If the allegedly defamatory assertion is an expression of opinion rather than a statement of fact, defamation claims usually cannot be brought because opinions are inherently not falsifiable." also "In Common Law it is usually a requirement that this claim be false." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defamation#Defences http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defamation#Defences
- zaptheimpaler 14y ago>It's also not simply offending language that equals defamation. Based on the post, many of the tweets were insult - direct attacks against the author, and not simply criticism/opinions. All but 4 states in the US also recognize cases of defamation per se, where the truth of the claims is irrelevant, and the damages are predetermined. Claims which impute the following fall under that category (I've omitted 2 of the 4): 1. Allegations or imputations "injurious to another in their trade, business, or profession" 2. Allegations or imputations "of loathsome disease" (historically leprosy and sexually transmitted disease, now also including mental illness) Many of the tweets directed at him fall into that category, and hence are defamation per se.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 14y agoDefamation per se is very limited under the First Amendment, and mostly historical at this point, dating from an era when courts would entertain prosecutions for calling someone's honor into question. To the extent it survives, it's been limited mostly to where "regular" defamation would also apply, to false statements of fact. For example, "injurious to another in their trade" can't be used to prosecute any comment that could harm someone's business, but only false factual statements that could do so, such as accusing someone of selling counterfeit parts. Nowadays the only real distinction is in showing damages: in a per se category, once defamation is proven, the plaintiff doesn't have to further prove that they were harmed, because harm is assumed in those categories. I think mostly we're discussing something else here, angry and vitriolic "piling-on" responses, which is a different issue from defaming someone.
- bo1024 14y agoThe point is, some types of free speech should be encouraged and some types discouraged. I think you should be allowed to flame people, but I'm not obligated to provide you a venue to do so, and I'd really rather you didn't.
- true_religion 14y agoI really do believe arguments about the 'freedom' of speech should be kept to the context of government versus the populace. The government censors people through force, sometimes in autocracies this quite literally means a gun to a dissenter's head. It is a separate thing all together, On the other hand, if individuals freely choose to criticize, flame, or just simple disassociate themselves with someone else because they disapprove of their opinions. We should all be free to do at least this without fear that merely by agreeing with the majority we will be accused of 'censoring' the minority.
- ynniv 14y agoMost responses were zingers or did not show a basic understanding for what he said. They are noise, and noise is not worth defending. I take his argument as supporting individual merit, and condemning praise for the seemingly meritless based on being a minority (what is often called affermative action). A proper disagreement with this position might be based around a purposeful cultivation of the minority to overcome the historical imbalance or avoid a flawed evaluation of merit. Debate then between cultivation and pure meritocracy is a valuable exchange, both sides of which are worth defending. There appear to be many responses to sound bites taken out of context. Many of them are additionally vitriolic reiterations of much less insight and nuance than what antirez said. They do not contribute to progressing the core discussion, and are only valuable to the extent that we attempt to answer a subtle social issue by taking a vote of twitter users. Which is to say, they are not valuable at all.
- _pius 14y agoMost responses were zingers or did not show a basic understanding for what he said. They are noise, and noise is not worth defending. Surely you see the problem with that line of argument. His piece was hardly insightful. In fact, he did not show a basic understanding of the issues he was pontificating on and the piece was mere noise, not worth defending by anyone. Once you start trying to parse out who's right, you're missing the point of free speech aren't you?
- ynniv 14y agoYou're pandering, but you do raise the point that I should have said "worth considering". All speech is worth defending as free, but our time in life is limited and we must each be selective about what we spend it on. Whether or not you appreciated his post, it is probably a waste of your time to make shallow, unsubstantiated comments regarding it.
- _pius 14y agoFor what it's worth, I'm not pandering ... that's more or less how I feel about his piece. But the point is, neither you nor I can have it both ways: free speech isn't just about protecting speech we like or think is substantive.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]