4 ms·
"Ulysses" is perhaps the most written about book ever after the Bible, which should tell you something. It's definitely a better read. Sláinte! The writer is a
by jseliger 14y ago
"Ulysses" is perhaps the most written about book ever after the Bible, which should tell you something. It's definitely a better read. Sláinte!
The writer is also missing something important: it's virtually impossible for a normal person, or even an abnormal person, to read Ulysses without a guide to the book that describes its allusions and what's going on. If you're trying to read Ulysses without the superstructure of a guidebook or guidebooks, or a class, you're almost certainly going to fail, because very little of it, taken as a free-standing narrative, makes any sense. This is doubly true for those without an in-depth understanding of Irish history and religious practices / cultures.
I read Ulysses in a grad seminar, one or two episodes per week. Without that guidance, I don't think I would've finished. Or could have, in any meaningful sense of the word.
Ulysses seems like it was written to be written about, or to be treated like a puzzle, more than to be read like a novel. Some people obviously enjoy this sort of thing. I don't think I'm one.
- madrona 14y agoWhen I went on a foreign exchange trip to China in HS, I brought along a bunch of coursework for my other classes back home. Of all the books I chose to write a report about, I chose Ulysses, because of its critical reception. Once I arrived in China I cracked open the book for the first time, and the nightmare began. I searched in vain for any English-language bookstore I could find in the hopes of replacing Ulysses with something more... comprehensible. Writing that report was more painful than wisdom teeth extraction.
- w1ntermute 14y agoHow long ago was this? I can imagine the experience wouldn't be nearly as painful with internet access.
- madrona 14y ago1997
- w1ntermute 14y agoOh, wow, I can imagine that must've been pretty bad. What did you end up doing about the report?
- madrona 14y agoWaving my hands about the syntax and myriad literary devices in the book to distract the teacher from the fact that I had no idea what was actually going on. :)
- w1ntermute 14y agoHaha, as a recent college graduate, I can only imagine how much preparation must've been necessary back in the day in order to do anything. Nowadays, you can be completely unprepared and still make it work as long as you've got an internet connection.
- Jun8 14y ago"Ulysses seems like it was written to be written about, or to be treated like a puzzle, more than to be read like a novel. Some people obviously enjoy this sort of thing. I don't think I'm one." In one sense this puzzle aspect is definitely true, e.g. Joyce even said famously: "I've put in so many enigmas and puzzles that it will keep the professors busy for centuries arguing over what I meant, and that's the only way of insuring one's immortality." On the other hand if you rule such works out, wouldn't you also get rid of many important and enjoyable works. Much of Borges, Eliot's The Waste Land, DFW's novels and essays, Pynchon, Homer are some of the ones that immediately came to mind. My approach to these books is completely orthogonal to that described in the OP: Try reading it with no guidebooks, etc. If you don't like it, fine, set it aside. But if you can slug through at least the first part. Then, bring out the guides.
- impendia 14y ago> On the other hand if you rule such works out, wouldn't you also get rid of many important and enjoyable works. Much of Borges, Eliot's The Waste Land, DFW's novels and essays, Pynchon, Homer are some of the ones that immediately came to mind. But is Homer enjoyable? I don't dispute that it is important, or that it is enjoyable to some. But my memory of the Iliad from my freshman course on Western civ was that it was a cross between allusions which I didn't have the interest or patience to track down, and a long list of warriors, with eight lines about their family history each, who then promptly get killed by Achilles. Since then I've tried to read similar (maybe?) works of literature, with the same result. I tried to read Marquez's One Hundred Years of Solitude, but I'm sorry to say I couldn't get the point. It seems that the sort of people who enjoy Homer are, to a first approximation, the same sort of people as those who enjoy Joyce, or any other literary work where it is difficult to figure out what the author means. In short, I remain curious about how one might appreciate such a work, but I don't really buy your argument here.
- bdr 14y agoFirst of all, I think you're confusing correlation and causation here: "It seems that the sort of people who enjoy Homer are, to a first approximation, the same sort of people as those who enjoy Joyce, or any other literary work where it is difficult to figure out what the author means." For example, Nabokov is much more accessible than Joyce, but the same people who like Ulysses are likely to enjoy Lolita. Second, I would ask whether you enjoy any literature. Some people like words more than others. What do you like to read? Do you read poetry? Not everyone has to. People who study music tend to like more "inaccessible" music like Bach or Mahler or whatever, and I presume you don't think it's because they're being pretentious. I listen to more mainstream music. But words, I get and love. I haven't read the Iliad, but I loved The Odyssey. I read it for the first time two years ago (age: 26, translation: Fagles). It's full of sex and violence and dramatic tension. Expecting a dusty classic, I was surprised by how engaging it was.
- pstuart 14y agoHow about a kickstarter to create a ebook that has the guidance built in?
- barkingcat 14y agoA wiki like that exists for Finnegans Wake http://www.finnegansweb.com/wiki/index.php/Main_Page http://www.finnegansweb.com/wiki/index.php/Main_Page
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rubashov 14y agoI've had the experience of trying to read Nabakov and Nietzsche and in both cases being sure most of it was sailing way over my head. I kind of enjoyed the stuff anyway, but as a working adult I don't have time to screw around with secret decoder rings. Wish I did.
- mikeash 14y agoThe contrast between your comment, second-highest currently, and the highest one, which says that the book is fun and basically says that you'll only enjoy it if you don't take it too seriously (which implies avoiding the sort of superstructure you describe) is quite odd. I have no idea who's right, as I haven't even tried the book, but it's interesting to see such opposing opinions of it.
- cafard 14y agoAt the time I was reading it for the first time many years ago, I encountered in the stacks of a college library a quarterly devoted to the works of Joyce. At that point there came to mind Hynes's (?) remark that "Shakespeare is the happy hunting ground of minds that have lost their balance", accompanied by the suspicion that Joyce aspired to replace Shakespeare there. Undoubtedly knowing about Irish history, Irish literature, Catholicism, etc. helps one to follow what is going on. Yet I think it repays the effort of reading. I have read it through twice, once when younger than Stephen Dedalus, once when older than Leopold Bloom, and found that that my perceptions of the book had changed considerably, though I enjoyed it both times. Should "you" read Ulysses? Don't know: who are "you"?