43 ms·
Lets say you love reading. Then someone comes along and tells you they're going to give you 20 points for every book you read, and when you get 200 points you g
by Alex3917 14y ago
Lets say you love reading. Then someone comes along and tells you they're going to give you 20 points for every book you read, and when you get 200 points you get a pizza party. What happens is that for a few days or weeks you'll read more books, but after that you'll completely lose interest in reading and likely won't read any more books for years, so in total you'll read much fewer books than if you had never been offered the extrinsic rewards. We see this in all areas of life, e.g. studies show that people who are paid to lose weight end up gaining weight, and people who are paid to drive safer are more likely to die in car crashes. So when you see literally dozens of startups offering prizes to kids for exercising or brushing their teeth, it's highly probletic to say the least.
The original book on this is Alfie Kohn's Punished by Rewards: The Trouble with Gold Stars, Incentive Plans, A's, Praise, and Other Bribes. Pretty much the most important book for any entrepreneur to read. Daniel Pink also has a much more recent book called Drive, but I haven't read it so I can't offer any comparisons.
(And speaking of reading, one of the most cited papers on early childhood literacy, by Scarborough & Dobrich, found that reading books to your kids does not actually help their reading skills at all. Why not? They say it's because the most important determinant of later ability is intinsic motivation, and for every parent who is building up their kid's love of reading by reading aloud to them, there is another one who is diminishing it. So if your three year old doesn't like being read to, let them do other stuff for a few months and it may actually benefit them in the long run.)
- drumdance 14y agoI think this is broadly true, but there are niche areas, such as frequent flier miles, where extrinsic motivation works for brand loyalty. Several years ago (before 9/11) United did a really terrible job of managing customer expectations during a job slowdown by pilots. I really, really hated United during that time. I probably would never have flown them again if I didn't already have over 200k miles on my account.
- kevingadd 14y agoThat's an example of a case where you had no intrinsic motivation. It makes sense for extrinsic motivations like flyer miles to work there.
- sillysaurus 14y agoI wonder if it works for customers, but not for employees? Where broadly "customer" is "you're trying to persuade them to [X]", and "employee" is defined as "additionally, you're in a position of power over them".
- Alex3917 14y ago"There are niche areas, such as frequent flier miles, where extrinsic motivation works for brand loyalty" While I agree with what you're saying, I think this is a bad example because frequent flier miles work more as a barrier to switching, rather than a classical extrinsic motivator. (You overpay every time you buy a ticket, and you don't get your money back if you switch airlines.)