2 ms·
> Lawmakers really need to learn to use version tracking properly Not how reconciliation-based negotiations work. Behind every material lawmaker you’d have re
by JumpCrisscross 11mo ago
> Lawmakers really need to learn to use version tracking properly
Not how reconciliation-based negotiations work.
Behind every material lawmaker you’d have redlines circulating among their staff. Each industry group would have them circulating among its members. Each citizen group, too. These will be haphazardly combined among the groups, sometimes transparently, sometimes strategically. It’s still traceable. But not necessarily in one go, and probably only through a lawmaker who doesn’t want to look duped.
There was a good article on the immortality of Word recently that addressed this.
- simonw 11mo agoEven being able to credit a line to an individual lawmaker's office would be better than what we have now.
- potato3732842 11mo agoThey'll just negotiate who does what off the record and trade around like they do with votes.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> being able to credit a line to an individual lawmaker's office would be better than what we have now It looks like North Dakota uses a LegCo. If the edits were in the original draft, no lawmaker added them.
- Ericson2314 11mo agoNothing you write here is not compatible with regular version control systems
- Arrowmaster 11mo agoThe point is that they don't want it to be that transparent to everyone.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> point is that they don't want it to be that transparent to everyone One part, yes. The balance between compromise and partisan showboating shifts when everything is public. But nine parts, it’s just not how multi-party devolved negotiations work. Everyone has their own preferred system, whether it’s Word redlines, in-person edits, text and e-mailed strike-outs or possibly a formal version-control system. They aren’t compatible and they don’t generally have to be.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> Nothing you write here is not compatible with regular version control systems What systems are you thinking of? I’ve provided private feedback on state and federal bills. I was, myself, soliciting feedback from friends and acquaintances. In some cases, that was a back and forth over text. Sometimes it was redlines. I consolidated that into an email that was sometimes a redline, sometimes a strike-this-add-that. If I were required to use a state-mandated version control system (a) I’d flip out at whoever required that and (b) just push the consolidated version once I was satisfied with it from my end. Many other times, these bills are workshopped in person or—increasingly—over Zoom. Part of what makes that work is you can say something dumb, be corrected, and then not have that be part of any permanent record.
- cxr 11mo agoOf course doing things off the record is going to result in there being no record. What the other commenters are discussing is doing it on the record. That's the whole point of the thread. (Even if you disagree with the idea being implemented, that's different from pretending not to understand how it would work if it were implemented.)
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> What the other commenters are discussing is doing it on the record. That's the whole point of the thread Okay, take the workflow that I presented. I'm a private citizen. I'm not creating a log-in to some government git. I'm literally saying I think this law has this problem, and then I'm being asked to fix it. So I try to fix it, collecting the input I need to so, and then send back my recommendation. This simply isn't a flow that survives being overly formalised. > that's different from pretending not to understand how it would work if it were implemented I'm not pretending, I literally don't see it. We already have official committee versions, et cetera. What are you going to do, make it a prosecutable offense for two staffers to discuss a bill over coffee? The top of this thread claims it's difficult to impossible to determine who made these contributions to this North Dakota bill. Maybe it is. I don't know enough about their legislative process to refute that. But I'm going to guess it probably isn't, at least to the point that you can figure out which LegCo version first contained these fake minerals, and who submitted that.