3 ms·
> What specifically do we know about consciousness and life that's incompatible with this account? Nothing but all of it -- the metaphysical account of life af
by lutusp 14y ago
> What specifically do we know about consciousness and life that's incompatible with this account?
Nothing but all of it -- the metaphysical account of life after death.
> It's conventional to assume that living organisms are somehow the vessel of consciousness ...
Yes. What is unconventional is to assume that the consciousness survives the body in a different form. This would be like hypothesizing that all ice cream cones live on in a metaphysical plane after they've melted in this one. Before accepting this idea, I would want to see some evidence that is more than anecdote.
> ... but is that assumption strictly mandated by any particular empirical evidence?
Nope. Neither is this.
> How would you propose even to frame such an idea as a rigorously testable hypothesis?
Good question. But the absence of a reasonable answer doesn't support an argument in favor or life after death. The fact that we can't resolve the central question about consciousness in a scientific way, doesn't stand as an argument for expanding the dimensions of our ignorance into new, uncharted territory.