7 ms·
TBH, I think the appeal to "economic growth" is often the wrong argument and instead there should be a focus on maximizing benefit for the public and the indivi
by malandrew 14y ago
TBH, I think the appeal to "economic growth" is often the wrong argument and instead there should be a focus on maximizing benefit for the public and the individual.
Having lots of patents and stuff produces economic growth and jobs, just not for inventors, creators, manufacturers, distributors, retailers and salespeople. Instead it creates economic growth for lawyers, para-legals, judges, courts and patent trolls.
Recently it was reported that Apple and Google both spend more on intellectual property related activities than on research and development, and they spend a lot on research and development. This shows that there is economic growth, but it is not desirable economic growth the same way a disaster like Hurricane Katrina or Hurricane Andrew created after they destroy entire regions and contributed to those economies via recovery activities.
Instead the argument needs to focus on growth that is maximally beneficial for society at large. IP strong and IP weak regimes both produce economic growth, but in different vectors, but only a weak IP regime produces an economic environment where the availability and quality of the goods and services available improves while the price drops of those same goods and services drops. That is maximally beneficial.
- rayiner 14y ago> Recently it was reported that Apple and Google both spend more on intellectual property related activities than on research and development, and they spend a lot on research and development. I hope this particular bit of FUD doesn't take off. The study that reported this accounted for e.g. the Motorola Mobility purchase as being a "intellectual property related activity." While IP was surely some part of the Motorola purchase, it also came with products, engineers, physical plant, etc. It's ridiculous to chalk up the $12 billion spent on the purchase to "intellectual property related activities" but that's exactly what the study did. All the study says is that Apple/Google spend as much money buying technology as they do developing in house. Which is not news to anyone. Heck, many (most?) startups are driven by the prospect of an eventual exit in the form of an acquisition, and intellectual property is part of every such acquisition. Should you count all startups acquisitions as part of this supposedly undesirable Katrina-like expenditures on "intellectual property related activities?"