4 ms·
Being repeated since Windows XP days, and yet without Proton there is no Linux gaming.
by pjmlp 11mo ago
Being repeated since Windows XP days, and yet without Proton there is no Linux gaming.
- capitol_ 11mo agoAnd yet, without the software for Linux gaming, there is no Linux gaming. Very hard to falsify such a statement.
- pjmlp 11mo agoSoftware written for Windows, running with a translation layer on GNU/Linux.
- Tom1380 11mo agoWith better performance than on Windows
- graynk 11mo agois there a point somewhere in this statement?
- pjmlp 11mo agoA reality slap.
- graynk 11mo agoSo no point to make then, cool, I can get back to playing games then
- pjmlp 11mo agoMake sure to use MAME as well, those arcade games are also Linux, apparently.
- graynk 11mo ago1. Nobody said anything about Windows games being Linux games. We were talking about Linux gaming, which is gaming on Linux. Which - yeah - emulators also contribute to 2. Above being said, translation is not emulation and has much less overhead So many pointless semantics to dismiss something genuinely good and useful
- 2b3a51 11mo agoNot the parent or grandparent poster and not a gamer. The echo in my mind from the statement was along the following lines: I can do everything at work remotely from my Linux laptop as they use Microsoft365/Sharepoint/Teams/Outlook and all. I can just log in via Chromium and noone knows any different with one exception: the finance portal. I have to be on an employer owned Windows PC to do that one thing as it is the last 'native program' needed. Moral: enterprise-ish stuff is happening via the Web browser. Steam et al financing WINE/Proton and generally hammering all the sharp edges out of the compatibility layer for running Windows software on Linux. Moral: Complex Windows native software can be run under Linux. So, at some point in the future, does Microsoft just phase out Windows? Replace it with a really well engineered Linux with compatibility environment for legacy software?
- graynk 11mo agoGames work just fine through Proton already, except when they require kernel level anticheat. I'm fairly certain OP is just one of the purists who think it's not done "proper" until it's a Linux native port, which I wholeheartedly disagree with.
- pjmlp 11mo agoWhy should Microsoft bother, when they have Visual Studio and Windows licenses that game studios gladly pay for?
- M95D 11mo agoEmbrace, Extend, Extinguish/Exterminate? They already begun the Embrace phase: WSL. The smartest Extend phase they could do would probably be a "Windows" GUI on top of Linux kernel, possibly with some customized locked-down systemd, to replace the aging X and the mess Wayland created. If it gets to be at least as functional as Win11 is, it will instantly wipe out the other two alternatives - Exterminate.
- pjmlp 11mo agoCheck how many Linux contributors are on Microsoft's paycheck, including systemd author and some Rust people also related to Rust on Linux kernel efforts. Microsoft already has their own distro. And they don't need to bother with anything else, Valve with Proton, makes Windows, Visual Studio and DirectX the way to go for the large majority of game studios. WSL on Windows, alongside Virtualization framework on macOS, are the Year of Desktop Linux, regarding the latops I can actually buy on a random shopping mall computer store.
- chrisldgk 11mo agoThe translation layer doesn’t really matter though, does it? If a user installs a game and it runs the same, the user doesn’t care about the translation layer inbetween. If installing and running a game on Linux is the same as running it on windows, there’s no reason to prefer one over the other for gaming.
- pjmlp 11mo agoIt certainly does, because it allows game studios to keep ignoring GNU/Linux, even when they happen to have Android/Linux games written with the NDK, it is a Valve's problem.
- nkrisc 11mo agoSo there is Linux gaming, you’re saying.
- pjmlp 11mo agoNo there isn't. What is there are Linux users playing Windows games. There used to be one, sadly the likes of Loki Entertainment are now gone.
- malfist 11mo agoWhat do you call a game that plays natively on Linux? Not a windows game.
- nkrisc 11mo agoI don’t really see what the difference is. If they run well, what does it matter?
- caconym_ 11mo agoa) The vast, overwhelming majority of regular gamers who could potentially be convinced to try gaming on Linux truly do not give a shit about whatever line you're trying to draw here. b) Driving widespread adoption of gaming on Linux is a chicken and egg problem---without a significant market of Linux gamers, developers and publishers have no reason to publish native versions of their games on Linux, and without games to play, nobody is going to install Linux on their gaming system. Proton directly solves the latter problem, and may indirectly solve the former when Linux sees widespread adoption by gamers.
- gligorot 11mo agoThere is a chicken/egg problem. We should be happy it has a solution.
- pjmlp 11mo agoI would not call being dependent on Windows games a solution.
- badsectoracula 11mo agoThe file format and APIs used are irrelevant as long as the games work. The games work and that is all that matter.
- pjmlp 11mo agoNot when it is a castle on Microsoft's kingdom.
- badsectoracula 11mo agoSorry but that makes no sense, there is nothing in "Microsoft's kingdom" here, Wine -as you certainly know- is independent. The most Microsoft can do is change the API in backwards incompatible ways - but that'd affect Windows too, so there is little incentive to do that (and attempts such as Metro/UWP/etc to change the core ways of working with Windows didn't prove popular with most gamedevs). And even if Microsoft does that, it isn't any different than the 2394923th time a library breaks its API on Linux - Linux as an operating system isn't some monolithic project, it is a combination of hundreds of separate projects that for the most part work together like -sometimes misshapen- bricks on a wall. Wine/Proton is just another of those bricks (and history has shown that it tends to be among the more stable ones).
- timeon 11mo agoSure but not everyone is using desktop for gaming.