4 ms·
Unmasking The Biggest Troll on Reddit
- ck2 14y agoYou cannot say both of these things together and be a decent human being: I asked if he regretted anything he had posted, now that he'd be found out. No, he said. "I would stand by exactly what I've done." "My wife is disabled. I got a home and a mortgage, and if this hits the fan, I believe this will affect negatively on my employment," he said. "I do my job, go home watch TV, and go on the internet. I just like riling people up in my spare time." So the real answer is yes, he does regret it, will probably have real percussions that affect him and his family and saying things online should be filtered with the same level as if you were talking to someone in person. Free speech does not mean speech without responsibility.
- kennywinker 14y agoNot that I'm defending violentacrez, but to say that he fears reprisal does not mean he did anything wrong. It's really hard to get a clear picture, because I'm not familiar with violentacrez's ouvre, but being painted as a child pornographer would probably hurt most people's career. I've seen r/jailbait. It was creepy, but as another commenter points out, not more creepy than most child/teen beauty pageants. I think because it's on a strange + ungoverned corner of the internet, it was easily painted as illegal when it was only very creepy.
- jerrya 14y agoOutside the context of what violentacrez is accused of posting, those two statements themselves seem fine and why at other times we have a First Amendment right to freedom of speech and expression. I can imagine a patriot saying, I don't regret fighting against the British, but it still got me shot. Free speech does not mean speech without responsibility. But this cannot be an absolute either. If every time you open your mouth, someone punches you in the face, then you really don't have free speech.
- decavolt 14y agoFree speech does not mean speech without responsibility. Freedom of speech refers to the right to speak without fear of government reprisal or punishment. It has nothing at all to do with how private entities conduct themselves in regards to the speech of other private entities. People replying to your comment don't understand this, and seem to think freedom of expression equally applies to speech on a privately owned website. It doesn't.
- basehead 14y agoWhat galls me the most about this is the celebration coming out of the centrist camps. Sure, we punished some sad nerds for gawping at women they'll never have. Along the way, we made sure that "creeps" became a moral term-of-art and thereby conflated the yuck factor with legitimate qualms of ethics, used moral outrage and "think of the children" to make strong arguments against free expression, and not-so-tacitly affirmed that if there are pictures of you online (and you are a woman— "r/ladyboners" and Tubecrush don't attract similar sentiment) you will be probably be assaulted, and only through the actions of an unaccountable, anonymous, mostly male vigilante pseudo-police force can you be protected.
- gilgoomesh 14y agoThis action against violentacrez seems nasty and vitriolic. His only "crime" in the article is moderating/posting non-nude pictures of teenage girls -- while removing actual nude pictures of the same. This is not an actual crime and while society discourages non-nude pictures of teenage girls -- as it forms part of an unofficial no-go zone between adult pornography and pedophilia -- there are whole industries (modelling, beauty pageants, pop singers) that thrive doing exactly this to 16 year old girls. So Adrian Chen is creeped out by a legal behavior and decides to defame someone who is -- on all other apparent metrics -- a positive, diligent member of a number of communities. Additionally, Chen has heaped shame and entirely fictional guilt (since there's no crime) on this person to the point where he feels he needs to withdraw. Chen seems like the troll here.
- streptomycin 14y agoIt would be easier to prove his troll-ness if he didn't delete his account, but he was definitely a troll as well as a free speech advocate. Not that there's anything wrong with that, it's not a crime.
- shinratdr 14y ago> It would be easier to prove his troll-ness if he didn't delete his account Anyone familiar with reddit personalities heard of VA and knows he's exactly that: A troll who rolls with the punches and does the opposite of what people expect to rile them up. 99% of the subreddits he moderated were created by others and then abandoned or handed off to him against his will. He didn't create /r/PicsOfDeadKids or any of those weird one-offs. He did continue to post to them because reposting images from 4chan once and a while was easy and apparently the concept of someone actively moderating a subreddit like that amused him. He never deserved this witch hunt, and he's not a cruel or unfriendly person. The only bad interactions I've seen him have with people were those that try and provoke him.
- ck2 14y ago(while I was writing this you edited out your disagreement with the word "troll" but I'll leave this) The definition of "troll" includes someone who posts inflammatory material (text, images or otherwise). Doesn't have to be illegal, just inflammatory. Certainly you agree he is inflammatory, you just think he has the right to be? I don't think the "everyone else does it" argument flies either. I don't think doxxing people is right but that doesn't make what he did right either.
- sauteedbiscuits 14y agoFor those saying hes a normal guy who just likes trolling, the article mentions "Michael Brutsch had sex with his step daughter" He was also the creator of subreddits that dealt with glorifying beating women and children. He has 100% of the right to live on the line and be a griefer and/or troll. He also has 100% of the right to feel the wrath of people he pisses off. As a internet free speech advocate, I am sad that things are in this situation. As a parent and decent human being, I am not. He is surely on many FBI lists now.
- shinratdr 14y ago> For those saying hes a normal guy who just likes trolling, the article mentions "Michael Brutsch had sex with his step daughter" According to him, while trolling. Yeah, real solid source. Definitely grounds to ruin someone's life. Also, since when is that a crime? Or even immoral? It could be a massive breach of trust and immoral, depending on the situation. However depending on the relationship between wife, daughter and the guy, it could be just regular cheating. Or not even that. He didn't rape his stepdaughter, or coerce his daughter, or have consensual sex with his underage stepdaughter. What he did was have consensual sex with a grown woman he has no blood relation to and for all you know has no parental relationship with either. Hardly the "case closed" indictment you want it to be, even if it allows you to string together the words "sex" and "daughter" in the same sentence to elicit a knee-jerk negative response.
- kennywinker 14y agoWoody Allen did the same. He took a lot of flack for it, but people still watch his movies.