4 ms·
> ... treatment for depression. As long as people understand that what is being treated are symptoms of depression, not the root cause, which is unknown. I em
by lutusp 14y ago
> ... treatment for depression.
As long as people understand that what is being treated are symptoms of depression, not the root cause, which is unknown.
I emphasize this because, to a layman, the word "treatment" implies a method that addresses causes, not effects. This is not the case.
If I operate on a patient and remove a tumor, I am treating cancer. If I offer the patient a more comfortable pillow, I am not treating cancer.
The meta-issue here is the degree to which psychological conditions aren't medical conditions (yet) -- with rare exception they don't have identified causative agents, as a result of which treatments are symptomatic, and it's too soon to be talking about treatments (as above) and cures (as in the linked article's title).
Anyone who wants to claim we've either treated or cured depression need only stop the symptomatic treatment and see what happens to the patient.
> If we can find a way to get costs down we absolutely will make medical devices a first-line treatment for mood disorders.
For one definition of "treatment", yes -- symptomatic relief. But not in the general sense.
- seehafer 14y ago> I emphasize this because, to a layman, the word "treatment" implies a method that addresses causes, not effects. This is not the case. By this logic Tylenol is not a treatment for a headache. There are a lot of treatments that are treating symptoms and not causes. Good doctors and nurses will generally point this out to patients when prescribing something.