3 ms·
There needs to be a blockade for these rogue ships. That's the only thing they'll understand, short of being sunk.
by shmerl 10mo ago
There needs to be a blockade for these rogue ships. That's the only thing they'll understand, short of being sunk.
- TulliusCicero 10mo agoJust seize the ships and auction them off. Damaging one cable isn't gonna be worth losing a whole ship, generally speaking.
- lawlessone 10mo agoGiven the state some of these ships are starting to be in they might just be worth scrap..
- bluGill 10mo agoOften the cost to scrap a ship exceedes the value of the raw materials. Depends the ship as well but things like asbestos can drive costs up
- edm0nd 10mo agonah just sink them instead imo. they arent worth much.
- mmooss 10mo agoWho controls these ships and what is their perspective? I don't understand how we know what they 'understand' or not? Also, how do you identify the ships? Do you blockade all maritime traffic in the Baltic Sea? All too and from Russia? The first would destroy our own economy, the second is a certain act of war.
- shmerl 10mo agoLikely Russia. Their idea is to engage in war under pretense that it's not a war. What I mean is that they will only understand counter measures that you'd take in a war, like blockade or sink them for instance. I.e. they are already engaging in the acts of war, so it's late to worry about that, the question is what is anyone doing about it. Ukraine sinks their fleet in the Black Sea, and they understood it very well - they don't leave their ports.
- mmooss 10mo ago> What I mean is that they will only understand counter measures that you'd take in a war, like blockade or sink them for instance. Likely that is what they want. Do you think Russian planners are ignorant, and can't foresee that? This sort of game is long played in international relations. It's chess: You try to cause your opponent to put themselves in a bad position. Provocations are manipulation - it's obvious what Russia is trying to provoke.
- shmerl 10mo agoI doubt they want that. Blockade will undermine their war efforts which strongly depend on their oil and other exports. More likely they think countries around Baltic Sea are too scared to offer strong resistance, so they can engage in such activity with impunity. And they won't limit it to Baltic Sea either, they'll do it anywhere they feel they can. It's a mobster mentality. As I said, the only language they understand is response with force, nothing else.
- Sabinus 10mo agoRussia wants to show global south that the West is evil and aggressive and wants to encroach on and break up Russia. Provoking a European nation into military action first is the way to do that.
- shmerl 10mo agoGlobal south cares for Russia as much as Russia is paying (giving discounts) anyone to care for it, not a barrel of oil more. The most obvious reason here is simply mobster style intimidation. I.e. "You are helping Ukraine? We'll get back at you by damaging cables and what not". I'd say the proper response to such incidents is to increase military help for Ukraine and blockade / confiscate / sink Russian ships wherever they do this stuff. Ships which engage in that should be treated as hostile military vessels.
- mmooss 10mo ago> Blockade That is not an option. They might as well bomb St. Petersburg - it's a seige, an act of war. > the only language they understand is response with force, nothing else I see no evidence of that. Putin is in fact a political operator at a high level, and understands politics exceptionally well. Warfare is merely politics by other means, one tool in the toolchest (for people like him).