2 ms·
Smalltalk was taking off, before Java came to be.
by pjmlp 11mo ago
Smalltalk was taking off, before Java came to be.
- znpy 11mo ago> Smalltalk was taking off, before Java came to be. In other words: Smalltalk was the best in town until Java came to be.
- pjmlp 11mo agoI would say that was Delphi in the PC world, but yes in UNIX world, several Java vendors were previous Smalltalk shops.
- dented42 11mo agoThis very much depends on your definition of ‘best’. While your criticisms of the environment are valid, smalltalk is flexible in tangible ways that Java couldn’t match. Java took the OO model of smalltalk and make a bunch compromises that had big negative impacts on the language that are still there today. Smalltalk was (and still is in some places) successful because of its portability, flexibility, etc. while it hasn’t enjoyed the degree of success as Java, ruby, perl, python, C++, and friends it would be a mistake to call it just a you.
- travisgriggs 11mo agoI think it was Kent Beck who described Java as “all the elegance of C++ with all the speed of Smalltalk”?
- znpy 11mo agoBest is often a tradeoff among many things, including (but not limited to): usability/ergonomics, productivity, effectiveness, licensing costs and many other things. When you factor in all these things, no wonder that Java won.