4 ms·
> Every censorship system you build, even if it seems “good”, will eventually censor you and the things you care about Nobody is being censored. We regulate wh
by JumpCrisscross 11mo ago
> Every censorship system you build, even if it seems “good”, will eventually censor you and the things you care about
Nobody is being censored. We regulate who can buy alcohol or tobacco, gamble at casinos, or operate a motor vehicle without it turning into a slippery slope.
Politically, the free speech argument might have had a point if Silicon Valley’s most-visible “free speech” advocates hadn’t lined up behind an authoritarian who’s creating diplomatic tension (and thus domestic political capital) the world over.
- potsandpans 11mo agoAccessing information is not a harmful substance or a dangerous activity that requires training. The problem is that you are drawing the parallels in the first place. These are not the same things. This is precisely what a totalitarian regime espouses: information so dangerous it must be selectively distributed and access must be accounted for. Today it's pornography. Tomorrow LGBTQ materials are labeled as pornography. And soon thereafter you're putting in age verification to access non-state sponsored news, wondering "why is this required? should I be looking at this?" I have no doubt that these are well-intentioned attempts by concerned citizens and civil servants to preserve some semblance of a decent society. The problem is that it's _always_ coopted. _Always._ Yet we can't seem to help ourselves but clamber towards more consolidation of power in the face of some new hysteria. Your final point... _these supposed free speech advocates have supported an authoritarian, therefore they have no credibility_, _the only free speech advocates are in silicon valley_, _this is the only defense of free speech_. I have no idea what your point is. That a few capitalists used free speech as a shield to make more money, we should throw the baby out with the bathwater? I refuse.
- StopDisinfo910 11mo agoYou are putting forward a false equivalence between social networks and accessing information. Meanwhile actual studies on the topic show that social network actually creates addiction - who could have guessed when they were literally engineered for engagement - and have deleterious effects on health especially for teenagers. This is not a free speech issue. This is a public health issue. This is the digital equivalent of the tobacco industry we are talking about, not a library.
- betaby 11mo ago> This is a public health issue. Sugary drinks are sold in France without any restrictions. Won't somebody think about kids?
- stackghost 11mo agoWhat a terrible and entirely unconvincing argument. "$unhealthy_thing is not subject to restrictions, therefore $other_unhealthy_thing should also not be"? lol. lmao, even. Should we let children purchase cigarettes? Alcohol? Cannabis? Cocaine? The BMI epidemic in America tells me maybe we should ban sugary drinks. At some point, society draws a line between what it deems acceptable and what it does not. In two generations it is virtually assured that we/our grandchildren will look back on Facebook and TikTok the way we currently look at the tobacco industry. The way I know this is because the CEOs don't let their kids dogfood their products. Famously, Steve Jobs wouldn't let his kids have an iPhone. Mark and Cecilia didn't let their kids use socials. These are bad products designed to be deliberately addictive, and it turns out they're really only good at making people feel shitty and giving teen girls eating disorders.
- betaby 11mo ago> Should we let children purchase cigarettes? Alcohol? Cannabis? Cocaine? No. An that is illegal in France. Somewhere from 1960 if I recall corectly. Sugary drinks on other are somehow OK with the french and Macron in particular.
- stackghost 11mo agoGoodness it's almost as if society is imperfect.
- betaby 11mo agoRigh! And the best place to start fixing it a cancerogen France is famous for, which is wine. I guess that will be the second thing the french parliament going to do - banning the sale of wine. Health is very important, I guess everybody is in agreement with that.