3 ms·
The argument is that critics of AA are committing the Fallacy of Composition. Specifically when saying that since giving out scholarships doesn't result in equa
by anon84873628 10mo ago
The argument is that critics of AA are committing the Fallacy of Composition. Specifically when saying that since giving out scholarships doesn't result in equal educational outcomes, then we should stop giving out scholarships.
I am with the author on this one. Creating better educational outcomes (for all students) is a coordination problem.
- skibidithink 10mo agoCritics are typically saying that giving out scholarships limited by race is racially discriminatory.
- jibal 10mo agoThis doesn't address the question and adds to it a misrepresentation of the facts.
- skibidithink 10mo agoWhich facts are misrepresented? The point is that the author picks some arbitrary critique and calls them fallacious, when the core of the disagreement is elsewhere.