3 ms·
you really don't need any of this crap. you just need Claude Code and CLAUDE.MD in directories where you need to direct it. complicated AI set ups are mid curve
by asdev 9mo ago
you really don't need any of this crap. you just need Claude Code and CLAUDE.MD in directories where you need to direct it. complicated AI set ups are mid curve
- wouldbecouldbe 9mo agoIt seems to mostly ignore Claude.md
- AndyNemmity 9mo agoIt does, Claude.md is the least effective way to communicate to it. It's always interesting reading other people's approaches, because I just find them all so very different than my experience. I need Agents, and Skills to perform well.
- songodongo 9mo agoIf you can test how often it is being used by having a line in there saying something like “You must start every non-code response with ‘Woohoo!’”
- csar 9mo agoIt’s told to only use it if relevant because most people write bad ones. Someone should write a tool to assess CLAUDE.md quality.
- parpfish 9mo agoI refuse to learn all the complicated configuration because none of it will matter when they drop the next model. Things that need special settings now won’t in the future and vice versa. It’s not worth investing a bunch of time into learning features and prompting tricks that will be obsoleted soon
- AndyNemmity 9mo agoI wish that were true. Models don't feel like they've really had massive leaps. They do get better, but not enough to change any of the configuration I have. But you are correct, there is a real possibility that the time invested with be obsolete at some point. For sure the work towards MCPs are basically obsolete via skills. These things happen.
- dnautics 9mo agoi don't understand this mcp/skill distinction? one of the mcps i use indexes the runtime dependency of code modules so that claude can refactor without just blindly grepping. how would that be a "skill"? just wrap the mcp in a cli? fwiw this may be a skill issue, pun intended, but i can't seem to get claude to trigger skills, whereas it reaches for mcps more... i wonder if im missing something. I'm plenty productive in claude though.
- AndyNemmity 9mo agoSo MCPs are a bunch of, essenntially skill type objects. But it has to tell you about all of them, and information about all of them up front. So a Skill is just a smaller granulatrity level of that concept. It's just one of the individual things an MCP can do. This is about context management at some level. When you need to do a single thing within that full list of potential things, you don't need the instructions about a ton of other unrelated things in the context. So it's just not that deep. It would be having a python script or whatever that the skill calls that returns the runtime dependencies and gives them back to the LLM so they can refactor without blindly greping. Does that make sense?
- dnautics 9mo agono that makes no sense. the skill doesn't do anything by itself, the mcp (can be) attached to a deterministic oracle that can return correct information.
- AndyNemmity 9mo agoBut the skill includes the scripts to do things. So in my nano banana image generation skill, it contains a python script that does all the actual work. The skill just knows how to call the python script. We're attaching tools to the md files. This is at the granular level of how to hammer a nail, how to use a screw driver, etc. And then the agent, the handyman, has his tool box of skills to call depending on what he needs.