3 ms·
An interesting article about a project discussed from time to time here on Hacker News. It would be interesting to hear comments from HN participants in Chile a
by tokenadult 14y ago
An interesting article about a project discussed from time to time here on Hacker News. It would be interesting to hear comments from HN participants in Chile about this paragraph from the article: "Another barrier to creating a vibrant start-up culture is Chile’s harsh bankruptcy regime, which makes it hard for those who fail to start afresh. Also, the economy is dominated by a few vast business empires and an extremely conservative bureaucracy. Ironically, this is threatening to stifle a peer-to-peer lending business that Mr Shea, Start-Up Chile’s founding father, recently launched."
- andrewcooke 14y agothe latter (large, often family-based businesses) is certainly true. also, earthquakes[ * ]. jeez. [ * ] http://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/usb000d4jf#summary http://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/usb000d4jf#...
- funkaster 14y agoearthquakes are not a huge deal... unless you want to live in a coast city (and not because of the earthquake, but the tsunami), which you probably won't because most of the business are made in Santiago. Constructions regulations in Chile are very strict, and most of the buildings will have almost no impact even after an 8.0 earthquake like the one that happen a few years ago.
- andrewcooke 14y agoit was a joke - a fairly strong one (the absolute magnitude was not so great, but it was pretty close) happened in santiago just as i was posting. [incidentally, i agree absolutely that this should not influence the choice of anyone to come here - at most, you will have an interesting story to tell someone when you go back home...]
- vpeters25 14y agoI grew up in Chile and although bankruptcy laws are harsh, labor laws are even harsher and unlikely to change given the political power of unions: Employers are mandated to give 30 days notice when laying off employees. They also have to pay 1 month per each year of employee service. (employee been there 9 years, you have to pay him monthly salary * 10 to let him go) This law is good for employee stability and help keeps salaries low (employees with several years of service are unlikely to quit and lose the accrued severance). However you cannot show up one morning, close the curtain and tell everybody "sorry, company ran out of money".
- andrewcooke 14y agoin practice, if you employ a local as part of startup chile you will be hiring them as self-employed contractors (it's incredibly easy to be self-employed in chile). and the above does not apply. however, the above shows the kind of clout the richer classes have here. despite this being a question about conservative bureaucracies and super-rich family businesses, the unions somehow get blamed. i can remember my bosses complaining about "worker mobility" in the one chilean company i worked for - it suddenly wasn't an issue the day i resigned. [edit: one thing i think that startup chile companies should use to their advantage is the idea of an "american working culture". the chilean culture is to do very little for very long hours. in contrast, you should be able to sell something more like "we want you to work your fucking ass off, but only for 8 solid hours a day". at least for me, that would be a huge incentive. however i don't know if it works so well for young (just out of uni) chileans, who may not yet have the experience to see what a good deal it really is. chilean working hours are the second longest in the oecd, behind only s korea - http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DatasetCode=LEVEL# http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DatasetCode=LEVEL#. edit2: whoa that's changed! they are now in third place. curious. they were second earlier this year - http://www.acooke.org/cute/LongWorkin0.html http://www.acooke.org/cute/LongWorkin0.html exactly who to blame for this is unclear, at least to me. while i am not sympathetic to people who simply blame the unions in a country where the gini coefficient is so high (see above) there is clearly a problem. politics are very polarized - people may not understand that doesn't mean just communists, it also means raving fascists at the other end of the spectrum (if you speak spanish, peruse http://www.google.cl/search?q=chacarillas+1977 http://www.google.cl/search?q=chacarillas+1977 - if you dig around you'll find a list showing how many are now in positions of power). i hate to say it, but what the country really needs is some kind of tony blair who can find a populist middle ground that creates space for dialogue.]
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI wondered this too, I sometimes get a chance to talk to foreign representatives who are tasked with creating the '<your country here>' version of Silicon Valley. I've gotten it down to a few bullets: 1) A pool of risk tolerant capital. You need the capital to start the businesses, people pitch the money men for seed, series A - D, rounds. 2) A lack of regulation on competition. You need to understand that existing, powerfully connected, companies are going to get disrupted and you need to prevent them from killing off the startups. 3) A failure tolerant culture. You need to understand that Silicon Valley is awash in failures, they are everywhere, but they don't have the same sort of stigma they might elsewhere. This disassociation between personal failure and startup failure is key. Typically, the first challenge is that culturally the company sees failure as a problem for the individual "He failed at his business" which needs to morph into "One of the businesses he started (positive affirmation) didn't take off. (business failed, he didn't)" That is hard for a lot of people who have historically thought of businesses as things you put your whole life into. The next thing is pointing out to powerful people that their 'friends' will ask them to kill the very thing they are trying to start when it starts costing them money. To understand a successful startup you have to understand that if they are successful they start out by re-directing capital flow to (or through) them which funds their growth. I've used AirBnB a couple of times as a great example of this (although Uber works as well). Here is a startup which is growing by taking money that would have gone to Hotel chains, and instead putting it into the hands of these non-hoteliers. So the Hotels are going to be irritated and try to stop it, be prepared for that. The challenge is that the impression people start with is that 'Silicon Valley' is composed of startups which are always new "green field" businesses that bring great returns to modest investment. Not realistic at all.
- funkaster 14y agoThere's also a cultural thing about this: failing is often looked as a bad thing in Chile (maybe South America). This is slowly changing, but we still need to inject the idea that failing is just part of the learning process. About the empires and monopolies, totally true. Also bureaucracy... although it's improving now (also slowly :P)