3 ms·
I was going to reply privately, but could find no contact details. I see you espouse HN Notify, so I'm hoping you'll see this response. My duplicate detector f
by ColinWright 14y ago
I was going to reply privately, but could find no contact details. I see you espouse HN Notify, so I'm hoping you'll see this response.
My duplicate detector found the initial pair almost immediately. I did nothing, because there was no discussion, so I didn't know which one to point to. Then the third came. Still no discussion. I watched in considerable dismay as a submission that I thought was absolutely excellent, and deserving of significant discussion, sank without trace.
Was it just unlucky? Did no one read it? There were a few desultory upvotes - a few had read it. But was I so completely wrong about what HN would find interesting?
I couldn't believe it, so I submitted it again over a month later. Still no upvotes, still no discussion. It seemed I was wrong about the audience here.
And now I can see that I was right about HN being interested in deeply technical issues like this, and I'm happy. I'm less happy that a brilliant item like this took four submissions, sorry, five submissions before it got noticed.
That's why now I generally try to point out duplicates in two circumstances. One is when they come close together, and that's to help stop a split discussion. The other is when there was a significant discussion on an earlier occasion, and I want people to benefit from previous comments.
So no, I don't think it's a case of glass houses.
- wglb 14y ago> But was I so completely wrong about what HN would find interesting? I don't think so. Whether a good submission gets noticed and upvoted early depends quite a bit on what time of day it is submitted. I have formed the opinion that 0700 eastern might be the best time, as the east coast sees it, UK sees it, and if something gets a few upvotes within a few minutes, it is likely to hit the front page, at which point it much more likely to be evaluated on its merits. Keep in mind that upvotes come from two sources. First is if someone is viewing an HN page, perhaps /newest and likes the article, clicks uparrow. The other way is if another user submits the same link, it gets an automatic update. So if a popular twit is noticed and submitted, the chance of a handful of submissions in a few minutes is higher. And I have a suspicion that if one were to tally the number of times the uparrow was hit on the front page as opposed to the /newest page, the front page would be vastly higher.