7 ms·
I guess nobody has told kids about what adults do with their grocery store loyalty cards: randomly trade them with other people so the data becomes less useful.
by jrockway 14y ago
I guess nobody has told kids about what adults do with their grocery store loyalty cards: randomly trade them with other people so the data becomes less useful.
Also, which RFID technology are they using? The readers look like Octopus card readers. (Which is FeLiCa-based.) I doubt the claim that the cards are "always broadcasting" and that designing a practical remote RFID reader is much more difficult than "parents" imagine. But even the federal government put some privacy provisions into the RFID passports, so you'd think that the same courtesy could be extended to high school students too.
- asynchronous13 14y agoFor $250, you can by a Motorola RFID reader that can scan US Passports and many other RFID tags. There's no need to design a practical one, just buy one off-the-shelf.
- SoftwareMaven 14y ago"courtesy...extended to high school students" That would imply that the people providing the cards for the students think of them the same way the government is forced to think about its citizens. Unfortunately, there are few organizations doing that forcing and the courts have often sided on the side of administrators to be able to treat them as much-less-than-citizens (which is a great way to teach citizenship in our country...).
- WiseWeasel 14y agoTrading loyalty cards with an acquaintance, when combined with credit card payment information, yields relationship data. That's just giving them more information.