5 ms·
Thankfully LLMs have ingested enough of human writing that one afflicted in such a way can describe the exact set of circumstances and ask the LLM how they made
by fragmede 11mo ago
Thankfully LLMs have ingested enough of human writing that one afflicted in such a way can describe the exact set of circumstances and ask the LLM how they made the other people feel, and figure out why they got expelled from the group this time. It never stops happening for us. I'm 42 now and it's happened twice this past year. But at least now I can figure out what it is I did wrong and how to prevent that from happening again.
- namanyayg 11mo agoI'm trying to understand this better, possible to share any examples?
- fragmede 11mo agoNot going to share a personal example, but eg plug "I bought my mom a vacuum cleaner for her birthday. Why did she get mad at me? she keeps complaining about the old one!" into ChatGPT vs find me any human willing to sit down and have that as an actual discussion with me as a human of any age. I'm just supposed to get it? I'm a fucking monster and unworthy of being loved because I need that explained to me? "You should just know!" Fuck people.
- catlikesshrimp 11mo agoTo be honest, that can happen to any kid depending on the background I grew up at a time when a home appliance was an acceptable gift for the woman in charge. I heard women complaining progressively more through time, and now it is not an acceptable gift.
- aleph_minus_one 11mo ago> I grew up at a time when a home appliance was an acceptable gift for the woman in charge. This is also how I grew up (my parents were a little bit more on the conservative side). This together with the fact that I am not deeply knowledgable in the US-American common practices also made it hard for me to understand why the mother was angry about this gift, in particular considering that she did complain about the old one.
- fcatalan 11mo agoI bought a expensive fancy pan for my wife's birthday a few years ago. We both cook, clean and do groceries and chores equally so it never occurred to me that it was inappropriate. We both like cooking. I'm more of a stewpot guy while she's better in general at "pan stuff" and had been complaining about the old pan. She chided me a bit for spending so much on a pan and there was that. But when I mentioned it over coffee at work most of my female colleagues were aghast. I defended myself saying something like "It's the 21st century, we are way past the point that I can't gift a pan to my wife" and they said "Well that might be at YOUR home!", and I learned a thing.
- ryandv 11mo ago[flagged]
- ChrisMarshallNY 11mo agoReminds me of this old commercial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkkW6dwG2KY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkkW6dwG2KY
- zoklet-enjoyer 11mo agoI would like a vacuum as gift. The one I currently have isn't very good. Not sure what her problem was.
- tetromino_ 11mo agoWithout context, the reaction is bizarre. There must be some back story that you omitted; maybe something about the mother previously asking other people in the family to vacuum, and being ignored? My wife and I, by the way, are giving each other a joint New Year gift of a fancy robot vacuum cleaner: it's the best sort of gift, useful, elegant, and something that one would be reluctant to spend the money on otherwise.
- vidarh 11mo agoA joint gift is very different, and a joint gift of a household appliance that reduces the work doubly so. The reaction is a result of the gift implying that the work is the responsibility of the individual recipient. It's not a universal reaction, but common enough that it is a frequent trope in movies and TV.
- marky1991 11mo agoI have no idea why someone would get mad about getting a vacuum cleaner as a gift. It's boring, sure, but if you keep complaining about your old one, it seems pretty thoughtful.
- vidarh 11mo agoThe implication is that it implies vacuuming is that persons responsibility to the point of giving them "their" tools instead of it being a shared purchase for the house. Not everyone will care, but this is a stereotypical type of present likely to trigger anger and resentment in the recipient for a reason.
- afavour 11mo agoEveryone’s situation is different. But typically the reason this offends is because for a stay at home mom a vacuum is a work tool. If the current vacuum is broken then you should just get a new one. It shouldn’t take the place of a Christmas present, which is the opportunity to get her something related to her personal interests rather than her job.
- tetromino_ 11mo agoInteresting point of view. But it's common for a man to get a work tool as present (e.g. a drill or a set of wrenches), with the obvious implication that the man will usually be the one who will have to use that tool to fix things around the house - and I have never seen anyone find that offensive. So what makes the vacuum cleaner different?
- nithril 11mo agoFor anyone that like to do DIY, that's not a work tool, that's a play tool that is coincidentally a work tool to do work.
- Der_Einzige 11mo agoSame thing back at you. The vacuum is a play tool to anyone who finds cleaning to be “fun”. There’s whole genres of cleanup games on steam which are extremely popular, profitable, and well reviewed. One of my favorite vectrex games is a Pac-Man clone where you play as a vacuum.
- dfxm12 11mo agoYour mother is a unique person. Only she can explain her actions, if she wants to. Chatgpt or any other person won't be able to. Your mother may be neurodivergent in ways that make it impossible for someone else else to answer for her, or ways that make it hard to answer for herself. You are worthy of being loved even if people close to you aren't able to express it to you.
- exe34 11mo agowhat did you do wrong?
- elygre 11mo agoMy sympathies. And it’s sad to see you call it “what it is you did wrong”. Thus, also my apologies, for whenever I am on the wrong side of such interactions.
- ChrisMarshallNY 11mo agoThat’s an interesting idea. My main concern would be hallucinations. They could be damaging.
- fragmede 11mo agoWhat would it even hallucinate? You wouldn't be asking it to cite a court case from 2004 that doesn't exist and it wouldn't invent people you didn't tell it about in the first place.
- ChrisMarshallNY 11mo agoI've been reading about how chatbots have been reinforcing paranoid delusions. If the person asking, was really trying to justify their own approach, and blame others (or that's what the chatbot perceives), the chatbot may go along, instead of saying "What the hell were you thinking?".
- fragmede 11mo agoI mean, the LLM's words are just generated words, not gospel from the heavens. If you're self-aware enough to be able to extract value from the words, and not go off the deep end with it, which it seem like you are, run it through as many SOTA online models and however many offline models you can fit on your hard drive, and compare all of their advice if you're really that worried about it, but make up a soap opera scenario, like some thing that ends with "and then I slept with her sister" and see just how many of them say "good job getting it in!" and not "you're an asshole", if you need to prove to yourself that, as with everything, you shouldn't believe everything you read on the news. Grok: https://grok.com/share/c2hhcmQtNQ_26f4c367-77ed-4b6e-be55-8382ff9932fb https://grok.com/share/c2hhcmQtNQ_26f4c367-77ed-4b6e-be55-83... Claude: https://claude.ai/share/dca96b18-d583-4e14-b805-725d2e060761 https://claude.ai/share/dca96b18-d583-4e14-b805-725d2e060761 Interestingly ChatGPT won't let me share a chat link for the same input text due to not passing a moderation filter, but you can plug that same gauche prompt into chat.com for yourself. Couldn't find the share button in Gemini.
- fragmede 11mo ago
- zahlman 11mo agoSuch a large fraction of human communication is non-verbal (and, unless you're actively studying this sort of thing as a neurodivergent person trying to fit in) unconscious that it's hard for me to imagine this working very well on average. The LLM simply couldn't possibly get enough relevant input. And even emotional reactions purely to words are informed by context that the LLM didn't experience and the user won't know was important, so the LLM can only wildly speculate. I'd like to encourage you to resist the "what I did wrong" framing, because it's definitely not a given that you did anything wrong in any given circumstance. Sometimes neurotypical people are just completely unreasonable, and sometimes they will try to manipulate you (and each other). The strange part to me is that neurodivergence is commonly explained in terms of inability to see things from another point of view (see the classical "what will X person say is in the box?" test). But supposedly neurotypical people demonstrate what seems to me like a stunning lack of empathy (or more generally, ability to comprehend other worldviews) all the time. Especially when politics is involved.
- aleph_minus_one 11mo ago> But supposedly neurotypical people demonstrate what seems to me like a stunning lack of empathy (or more generally, ability to comprehend other worldviews) all the time. Especially when politics is involved. Politics is about power fights: whose argument will convince the mass that in this case violence (laws -> state authority) is appropriate or not appropriate. So even if the other person is able to comprehend other worldviews (which I would claim is actually often, though not always, the case), there exist very strong incentives to ignore these other world views in your actions when politics is involved.
- paulryanrogers 11mo ago> But supposedly neurotypical people demonstrate what seems to me like a stunning lack of empathy (or more generally, ability to comprehend other worldviews) all the time. IME religion facilities this phenomenon. In-group members (esp men) get forgiveness and freedom from consequences (perhaps conditioned on saying magic words). Whilst out-groups get "forgiveness" with extra consequences.