2 ms·
Wow, great discussion here. My day would be poorer if I couldn't find out the scores that everyone got on a basic spelling/grammar test. <extreme sarcasm> In
by swombat 18y ago
Wow, great discussion here. My day would be poorer if I couldn't find out the scores that everyone got on a basic spelling/grammar test.
<extreme sarcasm>
In the spirit of informing the original poster so he can avoid posting this in the future, I'm going to announce that I flagged this, even though it's against the guidelines, because otherwise how would the OP know that this submission isn't particularly interesting?
- axod 18y agoIf this test has anything remotely to do with 'smartness', then I don't want to be smart...
- RiderOfGiraffes 18y agoCool. I posted something the other day of direct relevance to programmers and it got no discussion, no upmodding, and sank without a trace. Today I post a fun quiz that touches on mispellings and grammar. It gets upmodded lots, gets loads of comments, and flagged. I agree it's nothing to do with being smart - that's typical media misuse of the term - but that's not the point. Time and time again I see people mispelling, or misusing, words like lose/loose, or their/there/they're, and I'm constantly frustrated that hackers don't get it right. Some of them have good reasons for finding it difficult. Dyslexia is a real condition, evidenced by various brain scans and the like, and it can be difficult. But there's no reason not to try. And in case you think it doesn't matter, I invite you to read this post: http://neil.fraser.name/news/2005/08/20/ http://neil.fraser.name/news/2005/08/20/ Spelling, grammar, and other aspects of communication really, really matter. The examples given here are about communicating with other hackers, but the lessons translate to dealing with customers, investors, the press, and others. In summary, I respect that you found it uninteresting, but I think good spelling and grammar is important and relevant, even for hackers. This was one way to raise its profile.
- swombat 18y agoI agree that spelling and grammar matter. However, the page you linked to is not a good medium to generate that discussion (and in fact, if you look below, you can see there is no discussion of anything to do with grammar, just people posting their test scores and discussing the meaning of onomatopoeia). It would have been much more interesting to post an article that argued the points that you just mentioned. With respect to articles sinking without a trace, unfortunately this happens to many interesting articles on HN - which is why it's important to not crowd out the interesting articles with silly stuff like this. There are many articles in the "new" queue with a single vote that were more deserving of a front page spot than this. That's why I flagged it and posted about it - as that's the only way I can express that feeling on HN.
- jacquesm 18y agoOh come on, you're just sour because you scored 8/20 ;) Old school hacker on this end, new to this site and while I agree with your general sentiment I disagree with killing the subject once it gets past a certain number of active participants, it's a bit like a bully walking in on a game people are playing and tossing it out the window because you don't like it and / or are stronger.
- RiderOfGiraffes 18y agoI agree with many of the points you're making, and I suspect that we don't actually disagree on much. However, I still think that a significant proportion of hackers will find a small quiz like this interesting and entertaining. In making the submission I was using the guidlelines: What to Submit On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. You have disagreed, others have agreed with you, I'm taking that on board and will use this new information when I consider future submissions. I do, however, think it's more relevant to hackers than an article on tinnitus http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=462454 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=462454 or one on Nancy Pelosi (whoever she may be) RickRolling YouTube Viewers as reported here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=434046 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=434046 Being a hacker, and not being an american, I found that completely irrelevant and uninteresting. But that's me. I flagged neither. Perhaps I should.
- swombat 18y agoI flagged neither. Perhaps I should. I would have in your place, if you felt that the content was not worthy. I can make inappropriate submissions too, it's not like I have some sort of sacrosanct halo of perfection that stops me from submitting stupid things occasionally. In defense of the Pelosi article, I thought it was interesting to see a very geeky meme breaking out of the geek circles, hence why I posted it. I didn't expect it to gather too many points, and it didn't.