5 ms·
"There are major differences between the Trump 1.0 and 2.0 administrations. In the Trump 1.0 administration, many of the most important officials were very comp
by JumpCrisscross 11mo ago
"There are major differences between the Trump 1.0 and 2.0 administrations. In the Trump 1.0 administration, many of the most important officials were very competent men. One example would be then-Attorney General William Barr. Barr is contemptible, yes, but smart AF. When Barr’s DOJ released a redacted version of the Mueller Report, they printed the whole thing, made their redactions with actual ink, and then re-scanned every page to generate a new PDF with absolutely no digital trace of the original PDF file. There are ways to properly redact a PDF digitally, but going analog is foolproof.
The Trump 2.0 administration, in contrast, is staffed top to bottom with fools."
https://daringfireball.net/linked/2025/12/23/trump-doj-pdf-redactions https://daringfireball.net/linked/2025/12/23/trump-doj-pdf-r...
- stevage 11mo agoI would just do the digital version of that: add 100% black bars then screenshot page by page and probably increase the contrast too.
- netsharc 11mo agoIt's like Russian spies being caught in the Netherlands with taxi receipts showing they took a taxi from their Moscow HQ to the airport: corrupt organizations attract/can only hire incompetent people... https://www.vice.com/en/article/russian-spies-chemical-weapons-agency-hack/ https://www.vice.com/en/article/russian-spies-chemical-weapo... Anyone remember how the Trump I regime had staff who couldn't figure out the lighting in the White House, or mistitled Australia's Prime Minister as President?
- enaaem 11mo agoReminds of the time Russian security services showed copies of the Sims as evidence of an Ukranian Nazi plot.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> with taxi receipts Please tell me they were saving them for expensing.
- SanjayMehta 11mo agoOr the passports discovered intact after a particularly heinous terrorist attack.
- tor825gl 11mo agoThis wasn't a fuck-up though was it? Knowing they would die in the attack, the terrorists just didn't care if their identities were known.
- wkat4242 11mo agoYes I remember that incident. It was big over here. However I'm 100% sure that that was not a real spy incident. But rather just a 'message' to be sent from the Russian govt. The same way they have infiltrated our airspace with TU-95 bombers nearly every month for decades. Just a message "Hey we are still watching you". When you see how ridiculously incompetent they were, not just their phone history but also the gear they had with them. It amounts to nothing more than a scriptkiddy's pineapple. There's no way they would have been able to do any serious infiltration into any kind of even remotely competent organisation. Also the visible fumbling about in a carpark with overly complex antennas instead of something more hidden (e.g. an apartment across the street, a cabling tent or something). IMO the objective here was to get caught and stir a fuss.
- tdeck 11mo agoThe bigger difference from my perspective is that they have competent people doing the strategy this time. The last Trump administration failed to use the obvious levers available to accomplish fascism, while this one has been wildly successful on that end. In a few years they will have realigned the whole power dynamic in the country, and unfortunately more and more competent people will choose to work for them in order to receive the benefits of doing so.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> they have competent people doing the strategy this time They had a great playbook in Project 2025. I'm not convinced Trump ever had the smartest people executing it.
- tdeck 11mo agoYou don't need to be the smartest person when you're pointing a big gun at someone.
- Tostino 11mo agoHis last administration was filled with traditional Republicans. I may have disagreed with them on virtually every policy point, but they seemed to disagree with the most harmful Trump policies as well. We would have never agreed on the right policy, but we definitely agreed that his policy was not the right one.
- vanviegen 11mo ago> but they seemed to disagree with the most harmful Trump policies as well. I imagine Republicans such as this still populate a majority of the house and Senate. If they disagree, they are sure making an effort to do so silently.
- SirHumphrey 11mo agoThe amount of things Trump did circumventing Congressional approval might suggest that he does not a clean pass even though Republicans have majority in both the house and the senate.
- eviks 11mo ago> but smart AF. When Barr’s DOJ released a redacted version of the Mueller Report, they printed the whole thing, made their redactions with actual ink, and then re-scanned every page to generate a new PDF with absolutely no digital trace of the original PDF file. This is a dumb way of doing that, exactly what "stupid" people do when their are somewhat aware of the limits of their competence or only as smart as the tech they grew up with. Also, this type of redaction eliminates the possibility to change text length, which is a very common leak when especially for various names/official positions. And it doesn't eliminate the risk of non-redaction since you can't simply search&replace with machine precision, but have to do the manual conversion step to printed position
- plantain 11mo ago>exactly what "stupid" people do when their are somewhat aware of the limits of their competence Being aware of one's limitations is the strongest hallmark of intelligence I've come across...
- eviks 11mo agoSo following that strange logic if a dumb person knows he's dumb, he's suddenly become intelligent? Or is that impossible by your peculiar definition of intelligence?
- HKH2 11mo agoYeah that sounds like wisdom, not intelligence.
- awesome_dude 11mo agoWisdom would be knowing not to try and exceed those limits Intelligence would be knowing they exist (I know that I cannot fly by flapping my arms, it took intelligence to deduce that, wisdom tells me not to try and jump from a height and flap my arms to fly. Further intelligence can be applied, deducing that there are artificial means by which I can attain flight)
- ekianjo 11mo ago> William Barr. Barr is contemptible, yes, but smart AF You mean the guy who covered up for Epstein's 'suicide' and expected us morons to believe it?
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> You mean the guy who covered up for Epstein's 'suicide' and expected us morons to believe it? Let's assume that's true. How does it clash with him being "contemptible...but smart AF"?
- h33t-l4x0r 11mo agoYeah I mean, orchestrating an assassination in a federal prison of a guy the whole world is watching, and never even so much as a whiff of a leak? Because how do you contain that without whacking everyone involved (which we would know about)? You don't. Not without teleportation, time-travel, or at the very least post-hypnotic suggestion. Oh he's smart AF, all right.
- Ms-J 11mo agoThere were some leaks. Some of the events I would need to check my offline documents for more specific references but, for example, the Reddit leak with a person who was working at the jail saying that he had to let in someone associated with the military and they left shortly after Epstein was killed.
- rayiner 11mo ago[flagged]
- exasperaited 11mo ago> Had exactly did Barr and Co. accomplish in terms of moving forward the agenda people voted for? These guys were so eager to win accolades from liberals they couldn’t even pick the lowest hanging fruit. Are you talking about the same Bill Barr? "Eager to win accolades from liberals" is a hilariously Trump-after-he-fired-someone thing to say. Have you read his Wikipedia page? Do you know who he actually is?
- rayiner 11mo agoI'm not talking about paper credentials, I'm talking about accomplishments. 90% of lawyers in DC are liberals. Conservative lawyers can get credit for being "one of the good ones" so long as they don't attack the core tenants of liberal universalism or advance conservative social change in any meaningful way.[1] Obama's DOJ did stuff like go after Catholic nuns to make them offer birth control, to vindicate liberal principles like supremacy of secular values over religious values. Guys like Barr never did anything like that. Trump and his merry band of chuckleheads have achieved more legal wins for conservatism in a year than anyone in the Bush administration did in eight years. [1] It's not necessarily apparent from the outside where those lines are drawn. Bush's $8 trillion effort to blow up the Middle East was far less controversial among D.C. lawyers than Trump's effort to restrict immigration from the Middle East. Liberal universalists agreed with Bush's fundamental premise, if not his approach. Both believed that Iraq was the way it is due to external factors like Saddam, not internal factors like Iraqi culture. Even if liberals thought it was a terrible idea to go to war to topple Saddam, they didn't disagree with the core premise that Saddam was the barrier to Iraq becoming just like Iowa.
- exasperaited 11mo agoSo you haven't read his Wikipedia page then, and you are too young, I guess, to remember Iran-Contra. You apparently don't even remember how Barr got the job from Trump.
- groestl 11mo ago> made their redactions with actual ink, and then re-scanned every page That's not very competent. > going analog is foolproof Absolutely not. There are many way's to f this up. Just the smallest variation in places that have been inked twice will reveal the clear text.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> Just the smallest variation in places that have been inked twice will reveal the clear text Sure. But anyone can visually examine this. That means everyone with situational context can directly examine the quality of the redaction. Contrast that with a digital redation. You have to trust the tool works. Or you have to separate the folks with context from the folks with techical competence. (There is the third option of training everyone in the DoJ how to examine the inner workings of a PDF. That seems wasteful.)
- groestl 11mo ago> anyone can visually examine this. They can't, if the variations are subtle enough. For example, many people are oblivious to the fact that one can extract audio from objects captured on mute video, due to tiny vibrations. Analog is the worse option here. Simple screenshot of 100% black bar would be what a smart lazy person would do.
- _flux 11mo ago> But anyone can visually examine this. Can they? In principle it could be the difference between RGB 0.0,0.0,0.0 and RGB 0.004,0.0,0.0, that could be very difficult to visually see, but an algorithm could unmask the data with some correlation. If you do it digitally and then map the material to black-and-white bitmap, then that you can actually virtually examine. > Contrast that with a digital redation. You have to trust the tool works. While true, I think the key problem is that the tools used were not made for digital redaction. If they were I would be quite a bit more confident that they would also work properly. Seems like there could be a product for this domain.. And after some googling, it appears there is.
- g947o 11mo agoIt's not fool proof: https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/28/23777298/sony-ftc-microsoft-confidential-documents-marker-pen-scanner-oops https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/28/23777298/sony-ftc-microso...
- JumpCrisscross 11mo agoNothing is. The point is it’s highly precedented, surprisingly robust and far more competent than half the armchair suggestions being raised in this thread.