4 ms·
I read it and re-read it, and I still don't understand what it does or what advantages it has over... whatever it's supposed to have an advantage over.
by kstenerud 14y ago
I read it and re-read it, and I still don't understand what it does or what advantages it has over... whatever it's supposed to have an advantage over.
- tlack 14y agoHere's my take: I don't think this is an alternative to another product. Instead I think it's something fairly new and interesting: they built a tool which takes your tokenized source code (presumably only in Clojure) and your git log and makes a queryable database out of it. So you could query "who changed my kill_puppies function last year" or other semi-structured things, as opposed to a combination of git blame + ack + ctags. Like they said in the article, this would be the underpinnings of a larger system; something to manage code deployments, or an IDE, or a code review tool.
- stuarthalloway 14y agoAdditional analyzers can be added. The vision is definitely not language-specific, and Rich has already done some design work for a Java analyzer.
- jbranchaud 14y agoThe vision might not be language-specific, but the implementation will have to be. Furthermore, the language parsers will have to evolve as each language evolves. An advantage of existing versioning systems is that they are language-agnostic. Nevertheless, I am excited to see people pushing in this direction. Keep up the good word!
- Scriptor 14y agoOne advantage is that you can view your repo's history as a list of new functions being added/removed/changed instead of just diffs of what lines are removed and added. You could add editor support and look at all previous versions of a specific function you're working on. More specifically, where git mostly looks at code as a collection of files and differences in individual lines, codeq breaks it down into code as a collection of semantic units (function definitions for clojure, possibly class definitions, methods, etc. if other languages are supported). Your version control system would actually understand if a particular method had been moved from a subclass into a parent class, instead of just considering it as lines being deleted here and added elsewhere.
- drumdance 14y agoGreat explanation. This is one of my biggest frustrations with git.
- stonemetal 14y agoIt appears to be a git enhancement so that you get semantic diffs instead of file line diffs. It also has a query language for browsing code. Much as git is often described as a tool for building a DVCS this would be a tool for building an IDE (it would provide all the code completion and project navigation stuff).
- dribnet 14y agoHmmm, how about... A smarter and faster version of git-bisect - given an anonymous function, when does the answer returned change working backwards through the codebase? Or perhaps time warp integration - request a build of project foo but with library bar from the last tagged release version and function baz from a year ago.