3 ms·
Well, in recent years, I would mainly work in a DAW system like Logic or Pro Tools, recording each track of music by playing the instrument -- be it a real inst
by tjr 10mo ago
Well, in recent years, I would mainly work in a DAW system like Logic or Pro Tools, recording each track of music by playing the instrument -- be it a real instrument, or a virtual instrument played off a MIDI controller, or sometimes working with another performer doing a track -- so it was all about recording music in real time.
Whereas this system appears to emphasize a programmatic description of the music.
Of course, with MIDI, there's that underlying programmatic description, and you could use various means to work with MIDI in a more programming-style if you wanted, but I for one have mostly generated music either through playing an instrument, or sometimes through exporting music notation files (Sibelius, Dorico, etc.) to MIDI files.
To me, the idea of programming the timing and duration and intensity and so forth of a note from scratch seems like it would be harder and less enjoyable to do than to just play the note on a keyboard -- even if I turned around and applied some MIDI transforms to clean it up. But for someone who doesn't play music much, and is good with programming, this coding approach might prove easier.
- hmokiguess 10mo agoAh. That makes sense, thanks for clarifying! I play a lot of music, but I find there are gaps in which I require "someone" that this could fill for solo projects. For example, drum programming (I mainly play guitar). I often use Logic Pro Drummer and I enjoy it, but a programming interface and code feels more intuitive to my mental model there. I would love a "hybrid" mode for this.