2 ms·
I'll explain in more detail. Let's say you need a communications channel with a 300 Mbit/s capacity. Shannon's theorem lets you know what kind of parameters m
by klodolph 14y ago
I'll explain in more detail.
Let's say you need a communications channel with a 300 Mbit/s capacity. Shannon's theorem lets you know what kind of parameters make that possible -- namely, bandwidth and signal-to-noise ratio. From there, I can make an informed decision about the entire signal chain. Once I choose the bandwidth, the theorem tells me the SNR so I can assign a noise budget to each of the components. If we assume that the noise is Gaussian, we can calculate total noise level as the root sum of squares of the noise levels of the individual components (don't forget to multiply by the gain). I can look at an amplifier IC's spec sheet and immediately say, "that's too noisy" or "that's overdesigned, I think I can get something cheaper".
And thanks to theorems we got from the field of real analysis and statistics, we know that the sum of Gaussians is itself Gaussian. So rather than sticking two components together and measuring the noise, or running a computer simulation, I can simply square, sum, and square root.
Each of these theorems reduces the amount of work necessary -- whether by pen and paper or by computer -- by an enormous factor. But if you can describe in similar detail how the computer program would work, I'll acknowledge your greatness.
- marshallp 14y agoThat's just a few parameters that you avoided having to tune, a few milliseconds of computer time. I'm not great, just questioning basic assumptions that have been handed down from a time before computers were around.
- klodolph 14y agoYou keep on asserting that the task -- without domain knowledge of Shannon's theorem -- is solvable by computer. Can you describe how such a computer program would work? I'm unconvinced that the computer program would get a reasonable result before you run out of money paying for it.
- marshallp 14y agoThe Shannon theorem is basically voided by compressive sensing. But all of this (shannon+compressive) was a waste of practical people's time anyway. It's justification for pencil pushers who don't want to do real work.
- karategeek6 14y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1orMXD_Ijbs&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1orMXD_Ijbs&feature=relat...
- darkarmani 14y ago> That's just a few parameters that you avoided having to tune, a few milliseconds of computer time. Really? What happens when you need to do a similar calculation across hundreds of millions of data points?