3 ms·

Very interesting that a white noise track for babies is the 4th most popular track on Spotify.

• cluckindan 10mo ago
  Interesting if that is considered to be copyrightable. Any white noise track is perceptually indistinguishable from another, but none have the exact same sequence of samples except by chance, or if the noise generator happens to be deterministic as a function of time.
  • zarzavat 10mo ago
    White noise isn't copyrightable.
    • cluckindan 10mo ago
      Then how is silence copyrightable?
• al_borland 10mo ago
  I find it so odd that people then to streaming services for stuff like this. I have a dedicated white noise machine, and when I travel, I use the white noise (bright noise actually) built into the iPhone. Relying on an external hosted service would never cross my mind, and surely wouldn’t be something I go to on a daily basis.
  • junon 10mo ago
    It's not odd if you aren't the type who frequents hacker news. We are, after all, very much in a bubble here.
  • komali2 10mo ago
    You might find it interesting that there's an entire genre of youtube video that's designed to just be chucked one by one into slideshows for elementary school teachers to use as their lesson plan. Including videos that are just "2 minute timer for kids!" e.g. https://www.youtube.com/@Ask.the.Teacher https://www.youtube.com/@Ask.the.Teacher "Independent Reading: Count Up Timer for Classrooms": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AfLfJtVeME8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AfLfJtVeME8 straight up just stock imagery and a timer lol