3 ms·
> I wonder if, for instance, optimizing for speed may produce code that is faster but harder to understand and extend. Superoptimizers have been around since 1
by username223 10mo ago
> I wonder if, for instance, optimizing for speed may produce code that is faster but harder to understand and extend.
Superoptimizers have been around since 1987: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superoptimization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superoptimization
They generate fast code that is not meant to be understood or extended.
- progval 10mo agoBut there output is (usually) executable code, and is not committed in a VCS. So the source code is still readable. When people use LLMs to improve their code, they commit their output to Git to be used as source code.
- Wowfunhappy 10mo ago...hmm, at some point we'll need to find a new place to draw the boundaries, won't we? Until ~2022 there was a clear line between human-generated code and computer-generated code. The former was generally optimized for readability and the latter was optimized for speed at all cost. Now we have computer-generated code in the human layer and it's not obvious what it should be optimized for.
- erichocean 10mo ago> it's not obvious what it should be optimized for It should be optimized for readability by AI. If a human wants to know what a given bit of code does, they can just ask.