3 ms·
Developments in technology, innovation, and commerce are all inherently value-laden, because those things are nothing without their users and their uses and the
by BugsJustFindMe 10mo ago
Developments in technology, innovation, and commerce are all inherently value-laden, because those things are nothing without their users and their uses and their contexts, and values are politics. Eliminating politics from HN just means eliminating HN.
I notice that your style of pleading appears only ever on articles of a very particular subject category, namely conversations highlighting a particular US group being liars and grifters and abusers, and not on any of the other inherently political subjects discussed on HN, like
software freedom,
the value of historical preservation,
the moral position of hacking,
libel,
the justice of DRM,
privacy and the inherent injustice and dangers of televisions monitoring what you watch,
how old is old enough to use social media,
AI eliminating, or not eliminating, people's livelihoods that they depend on to eat, house, and clothe themselves,
whether AI training data is spying, stealing, or fair use,
the human value of AI-generated media,
whether warrants should be needed to access data about you,
whether data about you is yours,
the relationship between increased accumulation and centralization of wealth and decreased personal autonomy,
and so on.
I find it strange how participants in your refrain don't seem to see the politics in those conversations, only in this particular one. It's almost like your values and politics are showing. This suggests to me a non-rigorous understanding of the reach of what politics means and where it comes from.