2 ms·

"...what do you mean, 'World War One?'"

by xg15 11mo ago

tejohnso 11mo ago
I remember reading a children's book when I was young and the fact that people used the phrase "World War One" rather than "The Great War" was a clue to the reader that events were taking place in a certain time period. Never forgot that for some reason. I failed to catch the clue, btw.
- bradfitz 11mo ago
  I seem to recall reading that as a kid too, but I can't find it now. I keep finding references to "Encyclopedia Brown, Boy Detective" about a Civil War sword being fake (instead of a Great War one), but with the same plot I'd remembered.
  - michaericalribo 11mo ago
    Can confirm, it was an Encyclopedia Brown book and it was World War One vs the Great War that gave away the sword as a counterfeit!
  - JuniperMesos 11mo ago
    The Encyclopedia Brown story I remember reading as a kid involved a Civil War era sword with an inscription saying it was given on the occasion of the First Battle of Bull Run. The clues that the sword was a modern fake were the phrasing "First Battle of Bull Run", but also that the sword was gifted on the Confederate side, and the Confederates would've called the battle "Manassas Junction". The wikipedia article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Battle_of_Bull_Run https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Battle_of_Bull_Run says the Confederate name was "First Manassas" (I might be misremembering exactly what this book I read as a child said). Also I'm pretty sure it was specifically "Encyclopedia Brown Solves Them All" that this mystery appeared in. If someone has a copy of the book or cares to dig it up, they could confirm my memory.
- BeefySwain 11mo ago
  Pendragon?
- wat10000 11mo ago
  It wouldn’t be totally implausible to use that phrase between the wars. The name “the First World War” was used as early as 1920, although not very common.
- alberto_ol 11mo ago
  I remember that the brother of my grandmother who fought in ww1 called it simply "the war" ("sa gherra" in his dialect/language).
inferiorhuman 11mo ago
… what do you mean, an internet where everything wasn't hidden behind anti-bot captchas?
gaius_baltar 11mo ago
> "...what do you mean, 'World War One?'" Oh sorry, spoilers. (Hell, I miss Capaldi)

"...what do you mean, 'World War One?'"

by xg15 11mo ago

"...what do you mean, 'World War One?'"

I remember reading a children's book when I was young and the fact that people used the phrase "World War One" rather than "The Great War" was a clue to the reader that events were taking place in a certain time period. Never forgot that for some reason. I failed to catch the clue, btw.

bradfitz 11mo ago
I seem to recall reading that as a kid too, but I can't find it now. I keep finding references to "Encyclopedia Brown, Boy Detective" about a Civil War sword being fake (instead of a Great War one), but with the same plot I'd remembered.
- michaericalribo 11mo ago
  Can confirm, it was an Encyclopedia Brown book and it was World War One vs the Great War that gave away the sword as a counterfeit!
- JuniperMesos 11mo ago
  The Encyclopedia Brown story I remember reading as a kid involved a Civil War era sword with an inscription saying it was given on the occasion of the First Battle of Bull Run. The clues that the sword was a modern fake were the phrasing "First Battle of Bull Run", but also that the sword was gifted on the Confederate side, and the Confederates would've called the battle "Manassas Junction". The wikipedia article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Battle_of_Bull_Run https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Battle_of_Bull_Run says the Confederate name was "First Manassas" (I might be misremembering exactly what this book I read as a child said). Also I'm pretty sure it was specifically "Encyclopedia Brown Solves Them All" that this mystery appeared in. If someone has a copy of the book or cares to dig it up, they could confirm my memory.
BeefySwain 11mo ago
Pendragon?
wat10000 11mo ago
It wouldn’t be totally implausible to use that phrase between the wars. The name “the First World War” was used as early as 1920, although not very common.
alberto_ol 11mo ago
I remember that the brother of my grandmother who fought in ww1 called it simply "the war" ("sa gherra" in his dialect/language).

inferiorhuman 11mo ago

… what do you mean, an internet where everything wasn't hidden behind anti-bot captchas?

gaius_baltar 11mo ago

> "...what do you mean, 'World War One?'" Oh sorry, spoilers. (Hell, I miss Capaldi)