4 ms·

> simple, obvious answer to the effect of "yes, we understand extensions are a core feature of our browser and we plan to fully support extensions on Fenix and

> simple, obvious answer to the effect of "yes, we understand extensions are a core feature of our browser and we plan to fully support extensions on Fenix and won't consider it done until we do". Instead, they talked about whitelisting a handful of extensions, and took three years from shipping Fenix as stable before they had a broad open extension ecosystem up and running again. That answer is not as obvious to me as you claim it is. I don't use any browser extensions except 1password, which I would have no reason to use on a phone (at least assuming Android has builtin password manager functionality like iOS does). I think you overestimate what fraction of people care about extensions.

smlavine 10mo ago
I use Firefox on Android perhaps entirely because it supports uBlock Origin and my other extensions. I would guess that of people that would ever go out of their way to use a non-Chrome browser on Android, the fraction who care about extensions is pretty significant.
- School-Cotton 10mo ago
  I would agree that it's probably significant. But it's probably not so high that a non-extensions-enabled Firefox for Android wouldn't be useful.
- seltzered_ 10mo ago
  On a different tack, I feel like I went out of my way to use Firefox (and Firefox Focus) on iOS and was thankful they had them during a time where everything had to use the safari renderer. IIRC Firefox Focus even had an ad-block extension that worked on safari
  - thisislife2 10mo ago
    Firefox / Focus (like all browsers on ios) actually uses the "Safari renderer" (WebKit) because Apple doesn't allow any other browser engine on ios.
    - seltzered_ 10mo ago
      Historically yes, but in some areas like the EU there have been some regulation changes in 2024 where theoretically there could be alternate browser engines on iOS but in practice it hasn't happened yet. See https://open-web-advocacy.org/blog/apples-browser-engine-ban-persists-even-under-the-dma/ https://open-web-advocacy.org/blog/apples-browser-engine-ban...
JoeBOFH 10mo ago
I am speaking from only my personal experience, but I would say the vast majority of Firefox users are using Firefox to avoid Chrome and Chrome likes. That being said I would say they are then more likely and inclined to also utilize extensions.
- homebrewer 10mo ago
  According to Mozilla's own stats, most Firefox users do not have any extensions at all: > Has Add-on shows the percentage of Firefox Desktop clients with user-installed add-ons. > December 8, 2025 > 45.4% https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/usage-behavior https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/usage-behavior Note that language packs are counted as extensions. Some have disabled telemetry, of course, but how many? Here we can only rely on our own observations, and of all Firefox users I know, it's zero. (I keep it enabled because I want my voice to be counted — people who have never lived in an autocracy tend to have peculiar views on this.)
  - glenstein 10mo ago
    Always appreciate people citing real data! I honestly would not have been able to guess one way or the other but unfortunately most comments are kind of hip firing in random directions that are impossible to keep track of, so it helps to keep these discussions grounded.
  - Aardwolf 10mo ago
    But what if you weigh this by usage time? The firefoxes without extensions might be hardly ever used
  - wkat4242 10mo ago
    I think the correlation of people using extensions and people disabling telemetry is pretty high. I do both myself. Even a decent password manager requires one (though not on android because it has an API for that). On android I do use others obviously.
wtallis 10mo ago
Why do you use 1password on non-phone devices?
johnnyanmac 10mo ago
I you can’t take the time to install a new tool. You don’t need it. And I think that’s a great mindset to have with not just software, but when approaching life. I keep lean and only look for an extension or install amd app when it’s clear what problem I have and want to solve.

smlavine 10mo ago

I use Firefox on Android perhaps entirely because it supports uBlock Origin and my other extensions. I would guess that of people that would ever go out of their way to use a non-Chrome browser on Android, the fraction who care about extensions is pretty significant.

School-Cotton 10mo ago
I would agree that it's probably significant. But it's probably not so high that a non-extensions-enabled Firefox for Android wouldn't be useful.
seltzered_ 10mo ago
On a different tack, I feel like I went out of my way to use Firefox (and Firefox Focus) on iOS and was thankful they had them during a time where everything had to use the safari renderer. IIRC Firefox Focus even had an ad-block extension that worked on safari
- thisislife2 10mo ago
  Firefox / Focus (like all browsers on ios) actually uses the "Safari renderer" (WebKit) because Apple doesn't allow any other browser engine on ios.
  - seltzered_ 10mo ago
    Historically yes, but in some areas like the EU there have been some regulation changes in 2024 where theoretically there could be alternate browser engines on iOS but in practice it hasn't happened yet. See https://open-web-advocacy.org/blog/apples-browser-engine-ban-persists-even-under-the-dma/ https://open-web-advocacy.org/blog/apples-browser-engine-ban...

JoeBOFH 10mo ago

I am speaking from only my personal experience, but I would say the vast majority of Firefox users are using Firefox to avoid Chrome and Chrome likes. That being said I would say they are then more likely and inclined to also utilize extensions.

homebrewer 10mo ago
According to Mozilla's own stats, most Firefox users do not have any extensions at all: > Has Add-on shows the percentage of Firefox Desktop clients with user-installed add-ons. > December 8, 2025 > 45.4% https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/usage-behavior https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/usage-behavior Note that language packs are counted as extensions. Some have disabled telemetry, of course, but how many? Here we can only rely on our own observations, and of all Firefox users I know, it's zero. (I keep it enabled because I want my voice to be counted — people who have never lived in an autocracy tend to have peculiar views on this.)
- glenstein 10mo ago
  Always appreciate people citing real data! I honestly would not have been able to guess one way or the other but unfortunately most comments are kind of hip firing in random directions that are impossible to keep track of, so it helps to keep these discussions grounded.
- Aardwolf 10mo ago
  But what if you weigh this by usage time? The firefoxes without extensions might be hardly ever used
- wkat4242 10mo ago
  I think the correlation of people using extensions and people disabling telemetry is pretty high. I do both myself. Even a decent password manager requires one (though not on android because it has an API for that). On android I do use others obviously.

wtallis 10mo ago

Why do you use 1password on non-phone devices?

johnnyanmac 10mo ago

I you can’t take the time to install a new tool. You don’t need it. And I think that’s a great mindset to have with not just software, but when approaching life. I keep lean and only look for an extension or install amd app when it’s clear what problem I have and want to solve.