8 ms·
Monsanto Seed Patent Case Gets U.S. Supreme Court Review
- mtgx 14y agoThe U.S. Supreme Court agreed to consider how patent rules apply to self-replicating technologies. Well, let's hope that if we ever get to have a Star Trek-like replicator, we won't have to "pirate" food and whatnot by using the replicator.
- stephengillie 14y agoI'm more concerned about the self-replicating part. I don't want human self-replication technology (aka childbirth) to become patented. Don't laugh, some genes already are.
- talmand 14y agoConsidering the current path we are taking, it is almost inevitable that there will one day be a claim by a corporation to "own" a child due to it benefiting from its products and/or research.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI hope that day comes sooner rather than later. I can already hear the marching cry of those of us wanting to reduce the IP stranglehold in the US: Think of the children!
- talmand 14y agoI think we can make the argument now that the current copyright/patent absurdities are harming future generations. It's just that for most people, if it doesn't affect them today then they don't care because they are likely incapable of realizing it will affect them tomorrow.
- ditojim 14y agoFTA: "The Supreme Court took up the case against the advice of the Obama administration, which said the Federal Circuit reached the right conclusion in the case." Is there any doubt who's side the president is on in this matter?
- emehrkay 14y agoMonsanto's business practices are the perfect example of what is wrong with the patent system/big corporate interests taking precedence. They've successfully sued people for cross pollination; engineered seeds who do not produce children; used their standing to get those seeds in just about every market; and they want, and will probably get, their way when it comes to labeling of foods grown with the genetically modified seeds. You brought up Obama's stance on this, but I honestly haven't heard any presidential candidate; third, fourth, or fifth party; talk about changing this nonsense.
- ditojim 14y agogood point: i will assume for the sake of my previous comment that good ole' mitt would also take the side of monsanto in this case. still, obama is currently in power, so his actions are more critical than any other politician's stance.
- hugh4life 14y agoThe guy bought the seed from the grain elevator... what does that have to do with seed saving? I can see banning the former but people should be able to reuse their seed. (BTW, I worked like 6 summers for Monsanto detasseling corn)
- talmand 14y agoFrom my understanding, if you purchase Monsanto seeds you explicitly agree to not reuse seed from your crop. You have to purchase new seed from Monsanto for the next crop. Which I don't feel I necessarily disagree with that practice. You made the deal so you have to abide by it. The problem is that Monsanto claims to own the rights to all resulting seeds from their original, forever into the future. This includes cross pollination. So they want farmers who never agreed to use their seed in their crops to pay up because nature does its thing and everyone's crop ends up with characteristics of Monsanto's seed. The solution is for every farmer to pay Monsanto or ban nature.
- LarryMade 14y agoMonsanto should be sued for polluting the natural bio-system and be forced to clean up their mess. Soon the fossil fuel companies will be suing hospitals from profiteering from their air contributions.
- TheAmazingIdiot 14y agoNo. Instead, each state needs to file trespass charges for every farmer who didn't buy seed and had their field cross polinatee. Then you count how many seeds. There's a trespass charge for each and every one of them. After all, their seeds are their property.
- dean 14y agoHow can Monsanto claim to own the rights to all seeds "forever into the future" based on a patent? Patents have a limited lifespan. At some point, the patent will expire, and Monsanto's rights along with it. If I were a farmer, I'd be stockpiling seeds for the day Monsanto's patent expires.
- amalag 14y agoMonsanto wants to argue that seeds are patentable because they are unique and involve human intelligence endeavour which should be protected. They also argue that GMO foods do not need to be labeled as such for the consumer because they are not significantly different from 'regular' foods. Any contradictions?
- mhb 14y agoNo. An analogous example would be if you invented a way to produce an artificial (human) organ (e.g., liver) that was indistinguishable from a natural one.
- atakan_gurkan 14y agoThat would not be analogous at all. An analogous example would be if you made an artificial human organ that (supposedly) serves an identical function, but is different enough that it is immune to certain diseases.
- mhb 14y agoamalag was suggesting that there is a contradiction because Monsanto is claiming protection because they have invented something which is 'unique' and yet 'not significantly different'. The analogy I suggested refutes that. Your suggestion that there may, in fact, be aspects of Monsanto's invention which make it different from what it replaces does not bear on amalag's original inquiry.
- talmand 14y agoYou are talking about having a patent on the method to create the organ, not the organ itself. It seems to me that if Monsanto can have a patent on a "unique" seed that at the same time is indistinguishable from a natural one then it can be argued their patent covers the natural one as well. Especially if nature takes its usual course where the natural seed slowly takes on the characteristics of the patented seed due to cross pollination. Which cannot be easily controlled in an open field unless Monsanto wants to crack down on all the insects involved in pollination. Oh yes, make the wind illegal as well. Based on articles I've read about Monsanto's behavior in this industry it seems they think they do indeed own the rights to soybean seeds in the US. If the patent covered the process of creating said seed then I can understand. But I don't agree that one can claim to be unique and generic at the same time. Plus if the resulting seed is indistinguishable from a natural one and the patent was on the seed itself then it would seem that the natural seed is the prior art to counter the patent in the first place. In your example, a proper comparison would be if the new organ is resistive to aging or whatever other common human failing that would cause one to replace the organ. Therefore, it is not indistinguishable from the natural one. It would indeed have a distinguishable characteristic that makes it different than a natural one. Then you can have the patent on the organ. But don't tell me you own the liver of the child of the parent who received your organ because somehow the characteristics of your special organ was passed down to said child.
- DirtyCalvinist 14y agoThis is one of those cases where the rights and interests of patent holders need to be balanced with the rights and interests of the public at large. Biotech crops are probably key to our survival and prosperity as a species on this planet and if anyone can simply grow some seeds and sell them, that will reduce/destroy the monetary incentive for creating new varieties of plants. (In some cases this does not matter, like corn and apples, because these plants do not breed true. But this is apparently not true of soybeans.) That incentive is what the patent system is ideally supposed to protect. That said, Monsanto's ability/propensity to sue any farmer who breathes in a bit of their genetically modified plant material needs to be curtailed.
- RobAley 14y agoCan you substantiate your claim that "Biotech crops are probably key to our survival and prosperity as a species"? There is little evidence supporting that that I can find. Globally, we currently produce more food than we need. The problems we currently have around starvation and malnutrition appear from my limited research to be centred on distribution, comoditization and other socio-economic factors. How do biotech crops (current or future) tackle these issues?
- mhb 14y agoGolden rice is an example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_rice http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_rice
- s8qnze982y 14y agoThat's the most common rhetoric example used in science circles. In real world, if those 670,000 people can't get enough food to get the basic nutrients, if they won't die from vitamine A deficiency, they will die of something else. The problem of starvation is of social nature, not technological one. There's plenty of technology to save lots of people in those countries, as they're decades behind.
- rmc 14y agoGlobally, we currently produce more food than we need. The problems we currently have around starvation and malnutrition appear from my limited research to be centred on distribution, comoditization and other socio-economic factors. Remember some "produced food" is fed to other food to make meat. What would you say if vegetarianism was legally required?
- chris_wot 14y ago"If it’s overturned, it will have cataclysmic repercussions for the business model in the seed biotech industry," Benbrook said by telephone. "It would basically end the agricultural biotech industry as we know it, certainly for soybeans." Two things: 1. Someone will still make money from it. Innovation will still occur. 2. Indeed, the industry will change, to a better and fairer one. Oh woe be to humanity!
- pixelbath 14y agoI was talking about this exact quote with my wife yesterday. "...will end [x] as we know it" is the most fatalistic way of wording anything, without actually stating whether it's a good or bad thing. Monsanto, you already ended farming as we knew it, and that seemed to work out pretty well for you.
- talmand 14y ago"Gutenberg's printing press will end lack of knowledge as we know it!" "Tesla's radio will end communication as we know it!" You're right, we could do this all day. I agree on Monsanto, I think what we have today was intended from the beginning.
- zimbatm 14y agoExactly. The society needs to be able to change the rules to make them more beneficial for the society as a whole. Can't exploit the hole anymore ? Stop whining and adapt.
- randomdata 14y agoOn our farm, we've reached a point where we cannot even justify growing GMO soybeans because the customers are willing to pay far more for non-GMO varieties. If that trend continues, their business model may be at risk anyway.
- ditojim 14y agoi really hope this trend continues.
- fpp 14y agoIf you want to get some non-mainstream or non-paid for opinions on this topic, the consequences for farmers in the U.S. and even more in developing countries, also on how the PTO started to allow such patents in the first place watch Food Inc - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food,_Inc http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food,_Inc.
- mbell 14y agoOff topic: The snapping of the header into a fixed position on this web site is incredibly annoying. I thought my trackpad was spazing out for a bit till i realized they actually intended for the header to snap down to cover half the first paragraph, losing my place in the text in the process.
- joering2 14y agodont you love that company... they offer a farmer genetically polluted product that even bugs die of eating (and somehow magically they wont affect human organism, now and in 40 years of constant eating), farmer says "no thank you", then they buy a land around his, put their seeds on, wind blows them on the farmer land, then they sue him for stealing their seeds. By the time the case is closed, the farmer is bankrupt and in $XXX,000 debt. Its literally like someone broke into your house, raped and killed your daughter and in defense you knocked them off by smashing their head. Then you are being thrown into jail because you hurt that perpetrator and they go free because only you could technically prove they did the crime.
- sxp 14y ago[Citation needed] with regards to "then they buy a land around his, put their seeds on, wind blows them on the farmer land, then they sue him for stealing their seeds" If you are referring to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc._v._Schmeiser http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc._v._Schmeis... then you are eliding the part where "[Schmeiser] had used Roundup herbicide to clear weeds around power poles and in ditches adjacent to a public road running beside one of his fields, and noticed that some of the canola which had been sprayed had survived. Schmeiser then performed a test by applying Roundup to an additional 3 acres (12,000 m2) to 4 acres (16,000 m2) of the same field. He found that 60% of the canola plants survived. At harvest time, Schmeiser instructed a farmhand to harvest the test field. That seed was stored separately from the rest of the harvest, and used the next year to seed approximately 1,000 acres (4 km²) of canola." If there was a situation where Monsanto sued and won against a farmer operating in good faith after accidental contamination, please cite it. Monsanto may be an evil megacorp (See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Company#1997_WTVT_news_story http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Company#1997_WTVT_news...) but evil is not directly related to their GM work.
- talmand 14y agoI think the case you cited is the citation you are looking for. The problem with that case is in the definition of operating in good faith. If the farmer did not attempt to cause his crop to be cross pollinated with Monsanto seed then it's not his fault that was the result. He may have known what he was doing and took advantage of the situation, but that's irrelevant. Unless it could be proven that he somehow obtained the seed from outside his crop without going through proper channels then he did nothing wrong. He claimed to have replanted seed from his own crop and I don't see where Monsanto proved otherwise. Again, the case you cite is the citation you are looking for. Granted, I don't believe that Monsanto purchased the land around his farm with the intent to infect his crop with their seed, but the outcome is the same. The court gave Monsanto license to claim all crops cross-pollinated with their seed as being property of Monsanto. In this case, the court was wrong.
- Aloisius 14y agoThis never made much sense. I don't see what would keep some other company from coming up with a patentable gene in corn, spreading it all over the US, waiting a generation for it to cross pollinate and then demanding license fees paid by everyone. Heck, you might even be able to plant it near where Monsanto grows their corn for seed and then sue Monsanto.
- talmand 14y agoYou're too late, Monsanto's already doing that now with soybeans.
- bduerst 14y agoDoubtful, since the strain that goes to market isn't taken from seed from the external test plots. I think that if it ever came to that, all one would have to do is demonstrate that the gene is now occurring naturally, and they'd have a bonified defense against Monsanto. As it stand now, though, most of the farmers who went to court with Monsanto were found to be intentially trying to reproduce the technology.
- talmand 14y agoIn many cases that's where I disagree with the courts. Unless the farmer's intentionally obtained original seeds from Mansanto outside of normal means, then I don't fault them for taking advantage of their crops ending up with said seeds. Personally I would go the opposite route and do my best to prevent GM seeds from entering my crop. But that's just me. Plus, not reading the cases you are referring to, was that it was actually found the farmers were doing this or that Monsanto convinced the court/jury that this is so? Remember that requirements of proof are much different for civil court versus criminal court. Most of the cases I'm familiar with never got to jury, the farmers were bankrupt before getting that far or the farmers just gave in because it was cheaper to settle. Which I'm sure is as planned.
- bduerst 14y agoThat appears to be the case with the farmers though. In this article and with the Canadian farmer some years back, they were both shown to have intentionally taken the technology directly and tried to reproduce it for themselves. I don't know if there is a court case where the farmer truly had replanted seed of their own with the technology accidently pollinating it. Keep in mind too that these court cases are closed, and that Monsanto can be using technology to prove their cases - technology which is not public information.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nachteilig 14y agoPatenting genes strikes me as the only use of patents worse than patenting software.
- rayiner 14y agoTo be fair, this case isn't about cross-pollination. This case is about a grain farmer who agreed not to reuse Monsanto's seed, then bought seed from a grain elevator that had accepted harvests from farmers using Monsanto seed. So he reused someone else's Monsanto seed.
- sjwright 14y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't the Monsanto genetics be functionally useless when mixed with unmodified seed? If half of the seed isn't roundup-ready, you can't reap any benefit from it because if you take advantage of its one party trick -- herbicide resistance -- and spray your crops with Glyphosate, half of your crop will die.
- alpatters 14y agoIf Monsanto want their patent to cover future generations of seeds derived from a Monsanto seed. Would they also claim liability if one of those generations had a mutation that caused the plant to be toxic and kill people?
- talmand 14y agoOf course not, that's easy, they would fight all accusations of liability in that case. The banning of GM crops is already starting around the world and I'm sure companies are fighting this "unfair characterization" of their product.
- sjwright 14y agoNo, they would sue the people who are dying, because they would be illegally benefiting from Monsanto's product without paying for it.