8 ms·
I'm a Tech Lead, and nobody listens to me. What should I do?
- tkel 11mo agoDon't rely on hierarchy. Earn others' trust as you would when you are an equal. Don't expect deference just because of your position. Although hierarchical decision making may be more efficient, it's an unnatural system and anti-social and easily generates animosity. You'd do better to empower your peers instead, and show them you are able to listen to them as well. Just like you would with friends.
- wiseowise 11mo agoBig pile of horse shit, every word. Wasted years in previous company under narcissistic manager with the same mindset. The guy had official senior lead title and was calling the shots. When ther team became too big, he assigned most senior people as “leads” without the official title. You had to perform as a team lead in an environment where your decisions do not have authoritative power, so every small task became negotiation with every member regardless of their seniority. Also no salary bump either. The “teams” quickly collapsed and they hired official team leads from there, with a real authority. > Although hierarchical decision making may be more efficient, it's an unnatural system and anti-social Where did you read this? “Empowerment management for empowered to empower #21”?
- baby 11mo ago"Leading without authority"
- rolph 11mo agoin other words buffering of culpability.
- jcalvinowens 11mo agoNo. Never accept responsibility without power. That is a lesson I wish I'd learned much earlier in my life.
- rpdillon 11mo agoThis, and use power sparingly.
- 28304283409234 11mo ago"Here's a simple formula that solves this very complex problem that is different for everyone." Good luck with that.
- newsclues 11mo agoBecome a leader.
- fredsted 11mo ago> After that incident, I created an incident review document and suggested a small review of the tasks that should be prioritized to prevent it from happening again. I got carried away and created an initial presentation for the other backend Chapter Leads with a backend strategy. I do not remember it perfectly, but it included hexagonal architecture, a testing pyramid with contract tests to avoid breaking APIs used by mobile apps, and more Definitely got carried away. When coming to a new org, it's always good to learn the ropes a bit before fatiguing the team with more work, processes, and burdens.
- tormeh 11mo ago> hexagonal architecture God help me. Was on a project where this was used to justify so much extra boilerplate. Every class had an interface, and then we used dependency injection to supply the class to something expecting that interface. Actually, it was in Rust, so there were no classes, but that didn't stop us. Absolute waste of time.
- littlecranky67 11mo agoSounds like a regular setup, at least this is very common in modern C#/.NET when you implement REST services. Nothing to do with Hexagonal Architecture, just inversion of control. There is a very thin DI container baked into ASP.NET and the pipeline. Do you have to use that? No, but it gets complicated very quickly if you don't. So any project that is more than a tech demo/eval uses DI. In other languages/frameworks (i.e. Typescript+NodeJS) this is not very common for some reason.
- tormeh 11mo agoI don't know much about C#, but in Rust this is very much not the norm. In fact, there are technical limitations associated with async traits. This sometimes allowed us a reprieve from the madness, but only sometimes. I guess you can write enterprise Java in any language. The entire idea was to make it easier to mock components and therefore easier to test code, however all the code connecting the components became untestable, so we were back to square one, struggling to meet our test coverage quota because of the massive amounts of boilerplate.
- jmkni 11mo agoIf nobody is listening to you then you aren't a tech lead, just saying
- OutOfHere 11mo agoThis. If the lead has no power to suspend people without pay, or to fire people, then he is not a lead. It's okay for this power to be indirect so long as it can be wielded when necessary.
- omgJustTest 11mo ago"I'm a tech lead, nobody listens"... 1. Listen to what other people say and what they think the problem is, or what the problem "says". 2. Think, ask questions to clarify and repeat step 1. Is the problem actually technical? branch a. otherwise branch b. a. have you considered the problem is mostly not technical? then proceed to branch b. b. what miscommunications are keeping the solution from being implemented? 3. Change minds with the words that are convincing to others. Dont be so convinced of your solution that you wouldnt take a better one, return to step 1 unless the problem is "solved" My blog would be uncompellingly short.
- ionwake 11mo ago2c. is there a context I dont understand? I think its important to note in most companies I worked in, the issues were mostly political.
- worthless-trash 11mo agoBut very useful. I would like to subscribe to your newsletter.
- commandersaki 11mo agoThat Spotify squad tribe diagram makes me want to vomit.
- junga 11mo agoSame. Strong SAFe vibes. Hopefully I'll never have to 'work' in such a environment again.
- preommr 11mo agoI did a reverse image search on it, and it brought up 'vietname board game' and other war-themed images. Who thought it would be a good idea to have a corporate productivity diagram where the workers look like they're prisoners, there's shooting targets plastered all over, and the "coach" looks like a warden that's flashing danger signs (all the colors, and they choose red?). And that's not even including all the poor spacing, text formatting, color scheme, etc. Honestly, the more I look at it, the worse it gets.
- tuetuopay 11mo agoThis is pretty in line with the BS side of agile. How many retrospectives I've had with themed MIRO boards, from star wars to indiana jones with a step in whatever war. Par for the course I guess. (not that I'm defending it, aside from the more than dubious theme, it's plain illegible)
- azangru 11mo agoWhat's wrong with it? Squads look like regular small teams. Tribes look like several teams working on the same product and having to coordinate their work. Each team has specialists, who like to hang out together and talk shop, forming different "chapters". The number of product owners and agile coaches might be excessive :-) But other than that, what's so bad about it?
- franktankbank 11mo ago> The number of product owners and agile coaches might be excessive Its a great soup, apart from the turds floating in it.
- varispeed 11mo agoAt previous corporation, the tech lead simply recommended for sackings a developer who was questioning his approach. Once he got sacked, everyone listened... ...and then most of best skilled people left in the following weeks. Tech lead then hired his mates and company nose dived.
- master-lincoln 11mo agomust be an idiot that tech leads boss
- AdrianB1 11mo agoIn most non-IT corporations, the managers are non-technical and most are idiots these days. It comes from the MBA hires getting in management roles where they don't understand the area, what Steve Jobs calls "bozos" in his interview (available online).
- darkwater 11mo agoI met that exact kind of leader once. In my case, they also tend to work more on their personal brand rather than the company, and keep ship-jumping every couple of years to spread their gospel.
- Hydraulix989 11mo agoYou have to build / earn your influence. People listen to you after you have a reputation of being "right" enough times, and by being likeable. Abusing hierarchy isn't it.
- agumonkey 11mo agoThat depends on the cultural / politics health of the group. The likeable right guy can end up stomped because he's a threat to the wrong dubious people. Seen this first hand in some companies.
- pico303 11mo agoI feel terrible for the author, having to work in this kind of structure. Someone should tell mytaxi that even Spotify never got “tribes and squads” to work, it sounds like for the same reasons/problems mytaxi ran into. Edit: accidentally hit update instead of scrolling… One thing missing from the article that I don’t think has been mentioned is confidence and setting expectations. I’ve found if I expect certain results and convey confidence, people are more likely to follow your lead, or at least listen to you. Don’t act like a know it all, and be sure to encourage and question others so the environment is collaborative (solve problems as a group; don’t be a hero). But set expectations. Also, I don’t think you mean “intimacy.” Do you mean “empathy?”
- 9rx 11mo ago> Also, I don’t think you mean “intimacy.” Do you mean “empathy?” The words that follow support it being "intimacy". That is what intimacy is — being close enough to someone that you can be open without a feeling of being left exposed. How would empathy fit?
- socketcluster 11mo agoI've been tech lead at different companies. Every time I switched companies, I started out as senior dev and got promoted into the team lead role again; each time with full support of my team. I don't look or act like a leader and this has been a hurdle for me. But what typically happens anyway is; within a few months, my code ends up being a core part of the project; my modules become heavily depended upon and somehow I end up maintaining all the config files and guiding architecture decisions. One of my team members joked that I "conquered everyone's code." I probably write fewer lines of code than everyone else but somehow those lines end up heavily used. So then I basically just ask the big boss for a team lead position.
- master-lincoln 11mo agoI don't understand why that is a logical progression. Writing good code and leading a team needs vastly different skill-sets in my eyes.
- antonymoose 11mo agoI would argue that the two skills are necessary but not sufficient. If you’re lacking in the core skill, what exactly are you leading? If you’re a great coder and socially inept, good luck leading.
- zelphirkalt 11mo agoOn the other hand, if you want to lead a bunch of engineers, you should know their work very well, otherwise you will have unrealistic ideas about what can get done and how they should do it.
- master-lincoln 11mo agoIs this really true that you need managers to understand the domain deeply to manage? You could argue that a manager should have domain experts they can trust in their team to get estimates about time and complexity.
- Braxton1980 11mo ago
- DoctorOW 11mo ago> Note: this article is a translation from the original “Soy Tech Lead y no me hacen caso. ¿Qué hago?”, in Spanish. I wonder if "tech lead" coincidentally are two words that are the same in Spanish as English, or if this is considered a technical phrase.
- ioma8 11mo agoTotally not the same. Its used as technical phrase. In europe we have many languages, but in most of them we use the term Tech lead as phrase.
- torginus 11mo ago[flagged]
- wiseowise 11mo agoVery passionate comment with strong words, but very true as someone who worked in a similar environment.
- zipy124 11mo agoThis is a very long winded way of saying the phrase "respect is earned not given".
- general1465 11mo agoI still remember when my previous employer has lost domain for like 3 months. Boss and his business partner have setup company and I have joined later. Business partner left. - I was trying to figure out who have access to domain X? It is not on AWS and by whois it is under some random registrar in Europe. I got just shrug from boss. Everything works so why bother? - After 3 years of scratching my head and try to repeatedly get it to attention we finally lost the domain (card probably expired), everyone is panicking, because emails has stopped working, so email based 2FA are not working either which has cascading impact on all services. And I am just raging in my office because I was trying to prevent this situation for 3 years to no avail. - The European registrar did not cooperate at all. We have offered them good chunk of money, no response (weird?), eventually domain got moved around and reregistered by various bots and domain companies and I was able to get it again via domain backorder. I have left shortly after because this was just ridiculous lack of care with good amount of reactive behavior as a cherry on the top. My take away from this is that you can't change the culture. If top is bunch of sloppy clowns, whole company is going to be the same.
- wiseowise 11mo agoThis, many times this. If you encounter pushback from everywhere – leave, don’t spend your life energy fighting bullshit.
- nickdothutton 11mo agoI won't add much, but if this happens you must leave. Raise the risk. Document it. Document your recommendation and their decision, even if not replying or not making a decision was their decision. Tie it up with a bow on it, keep a copy, and leave.
- kamaal 11mo ago>>If top is bunch of sloppy clowns, whole company is going to be the same. This happens so often at big companies as well. Management is always assumed to be correct, and the pay grade argument always kicks in(They are paid more because you are beneath them). And this starts to show up everywhere. You can't take any initiative without sanction from the top, and they are often clueless as to what the ask is. Most of the times its rejected just to assert authority, and not on the grounds of merit. Top bosses are also very envious and proactively trying to kill rising talent out of fear- people better than them, will replace them. To that end no good thing ever happens, if you push too hard you will be eliminated in interest of self preservation. So by and large no good thing is ever suggested, or tried or happens. Eventually until whole business(es) die out. This happens in every company, no matter what companies claim about hiring, retaining and promoting talent. This is just how every place works.
- rvz 11mo agoLeave.
- jwarden 11mo agoListen to them.
- nickd2001 11mo agoIf its any consolation, perhaps there might've been a few other highly intelligent capable sensible people in existence over the last few... shall we say, millennia, who, weren't really listened to either ? ;)
- AdrianB1 11mo agoWhat I read in the story is the context and some action, but not the result. It is implied there is some sort of result, but it is not described, especially how the actions contributed to the result. It may be well intended, but very superficial, childish.
- ChrisMarshallNY 11mo agoWelcome to Hell, kid. I was a senior manager, for much of my career, and had about a 30% hit rate, with folks listening to me. My employees had to listen to me, but I actually encouraged them to talk back, if they had issues with my direction. My bosses and peers? ...not so much... This was especially true of the Japanese (I worked for a Japanese company). Even though I had a pretty significant level of influence (for a Westerner), I still had to beg for folks to listen to me. My favorite, was when my team was assigned to help a Silicon Valley startup that my company had made a deal with, after the ink was dry on the contract. There were a lot of problems with that relationship. Most of them, were because the senior Japanese management had made some really big mistakes; chiefly because of cultural differences between the companies (the startup was actually really good, but they were a fairly typical "smoke and mirrors" Silicon Valley startup, and had a different approach to pitching that didn't work well with the Japanese. Neither side really understood the other). We did our best, but our hands were tied. It did not end well, which was pretty disastrous. If someone had asked me to help out, before they signed the contract, it would have been a much better outcome. I'm no captain of industry, but the problems were pretty glaring and obvious, even to us mensches in the trenches. > I think I never read as much in my life as during the month between announcing I was leaving my previous job and joining mytaxi. I liked reading that. I would love folks to do that kind of thing, more often.
- nrhrjrjrjtntbt 11mo agoOh my. If self-otientation is the denoninator then dont advertise your thing multiple times. Instead keep that out and Ill say cool learned something and come back. At some point ill notice the course/book/whatever and be more interested.
- ramon156 11mo agoOnly thing I can say is that, what doesn't work for me, is leads that just tell you how to do things. I completely agree with my tech lead, but also it just includes only his opinion and it just leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Is this my ego? Maybe.
- FroshKiller 11mo agoI'm a technical lead, and I often tell my teammates exactly how I want them to implement something. I am not looking over their shoulders at every line of code, but I will tell them plainly that I want an interface, a concrete implementation of the interface that is up to them, and a configuration option for substituting a different concrete type. I don't do this because I don't trust them but because I have different requirements. What matters most to them is completing their work items according to specifications. What matters more to me is long-term maintainability of our projects for the rest of the team. Some of them have the long-term needs in mind. Some of them just don't think that way. I try not to make them feel like their work can't be trusted or like my demands are arbitrary. I think they are more receptive to my demands when I can at least provide context for them. That seems absolutely necessary to me. I ask myself all the time whether I'm insisting on too much control. I appreciate you asking of yourself, "Is this my ego?" It can definitely go both ways.
- 9rx 11mo ago> I often tell my teammates exactly how I want them to implement something. Ugh. I recently found myself working with one of those people. What a horrid experience. We waste days trying to reverse engineer out of him what the business problem actually is, and then, once we finally figure that out, even more going over all the things he failed to consider. Software isn't the technical Olympics. It sole purpose in life is to solve human problems. You must work from understanding the human problems. "This is how we are going to do it" obscures all of the information that is necessary to write good software. I have no qualms about pushing back to ensure that we start from the right place, but it is so draining when it happens over and over. Building software doesn't have to be so stupid. Don't be that guy. > I ask myself all the time whether I'm insisting on too much control. No. You're not. Someone has to wrangle those who are not providing positive contributions (without a forceful hand). But your job is to figure out why they are not providing positive contributions and solve for that problem, not to continually tell them how to do their job. You are no longer in a technical role. "Lead" means you are now in a people role, solving people problems not suitable to be solved with tech. If you'd rather be a software developer, consider doing that job instead.
- yoan9224 11mo agoI've made similar ones early in my career. The formula of Trust + Intimacy + Credibility is solid, but I'd add: solve one painful problem first, then earn the right to propose architectural changes. Ship something valuable in the first month, even if it's not perfect. That builds more credibility than any presentation.
- zkmon 11mo ago> Technical influence does not start with a title. It begins with the visible impact you create. That visible impact need not be entirely from your technical work. It is mostly from your relations, communications, the way you present yourself and the perceptions that you can manage to get from others. Infact, technology component is very little.
- agumonkey 11mo agothere's another dimension is how ready is the group to your ideas some teams distort the meaning of things, and if you try to bring improvements (QA, velocity) they will reject it right away no matter great you are.
- arealaccount 11mo agoI find tech leads to be the most difficult people in any organization to work with (always with exceptions), I think it’s because they are still learning the lead part, and at the same time are trying to prove themselves. Coming in with a hexagonal overhaul is a great example. At least in this case it seems the writer didn’t dig his heals in too much.
- baby 11mo agoI think it's also that they have a vision and unfortunately this means they have to say no to landing PRs that don't make sense to the overall vision often. And nobody likes to throw away work.
- lsofzz 11mo ago> I'm a Tech Lead, and nobody listens to me. What should I do? TL;DidntRead Precisely. Take the `TL` title out the door. Take the `ego` out the door. Then, step in the door - as a friend, with empathy, proactive listening and support the engineers. Round-table `discussions`. Not Waterfall. My 2 cents.
- pixel_popping 11mo agoAnother website blocking VPN and forcing users to reveal their identity, great.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- sceptic123 11mo agoNo need to answer this person's question, they are not asking for help, they are promoting their upcoming book
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- MyHonestOpinon 11mo agoOr just read all the comments and you don't need to buy their book.
- nextworddev 11mo agoOne of them could be sabotaging you so he or she can take ur spot
- retrocog 11mo agoThe trust equation implicitly assumes honesty. It’s a second-order model: it explains how trust forms among good-faith actors, not how to detect bad ones. Credibility, reliability, and intimacy all collapse without honesty — you can simulate them briefly, but they’re structurally unstable. Once dishonesty is detected, self-orientation effectively goes to infinity and trust snaps to zero. So the equation is a trust amplifier, not a lie detector. Useful for healthy teams, dangerous if applied naively in adversarial or performative environments.
- mixmastamyk 11mo agoDoesn’t only apply to leads, any new employee faces the same dynamics. Honestly it takes a while to understand not just what is broken at a company, but more importantly why. Otherwise the obvious fix might be a band-aid. Reminds me of an old post by Joel, “fixing things when you’re a grunt.” His advice was similar.
- rolph 11mo agomake it a secret, start with "dont tell anyone else but..."
- tacone 11mo agoJust for the laughs, some year ago I had to remind one of the juniors that I was the one in charge, not him. Since he looked unimpressed I asked him to hand me a pen on his desk. He promptly gave me the pen. "See? You're already doing whatever I ask."
- RickyLahey 11mo agosounds like that person isn't a tech lead
- BergAndCo 11mo ago[dead]