4 ms·
Wow, fusion power in less than 15 years! Gee whiz! Actually, the 15 years out time frame puts it beyond what I've expected, 10 years out. That's where fusion
by bediger4000 14y ago
Wow, fusion power in less than 15 years! Gee whiz!
Actually, the 15 years out time frame puts it beyond what I've expected, 10 years out. That's where fusion has been for most of my life, 10 years from now.
- Retric 14y ago20 years ago I remember everyone saying fusion was 40-50 years out and always had been. Honestly, I think the estimates where fairly reasonable when you consider the 30+ year gap between Jet which was designed in 1972 and came online in 1983 and ITER which is still being built. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_European_Torus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_European_Torus PS: I have heard that the real issue was scaling up Jet was assumed to be work but doing so was to far from commercially viable to be useful.
- elchief 14y agoIt should come out the same week as the anti-baldness pill...
- im3w1l 14y agoAfter iter is ready, in 15 years, they expect to have fusion for 1000 seconds straight. Just need to tweak that for 10 years, and then we are ready for start building the commercial reactors, which might take 5-10 more years. (extremely speculative of course)
- juiceandjuice 14y ago1. Who said it was 10 years out? I've never heard that. Sometimes milestones are 10 years out and the public tends to confuse milestones with the finished product. 2. Ideas for parallel implementations of nuclear fusion have expanded, and as a result, funding and research has arguably become fragmented and resources have been diverted. In reality, there's a fixed amount of capital and knowledge (which is also a function of the availability of money) available for this kind of research. The amount of money the US puts into fusion research is quite paltry compared to the potential benefits. It may be a priority, but the way Washington spends money says otherwise. Scientifically, fusion is maybe 10 years away. Politically, it's more like 40 for a real power plant, but with the current congress, I couldn't say. In addition to that, it's an expensive enough endeavor that it would be corporate suicide for a private company to attempt it, especially considering the majority of companies with enough capital to pursue something like fusion tend to be in the Oil and Gas industries.
- DennisP 14y agoWell, some types of fusion are too expensive for private companies. But Tri-Alpha, General Fusion, and Lawrenceville Plasma Physics are three private companies trying to achieve practical fusion power within the decade. Tri-Alpha has over $90 million in venture capital, some from Paul Allen. General Fusion has about half that, with Jeff Bezos as an investor. LPP is a lot smaller, but also doesn't need nearly as much at this point. There are several other approaches in the works that could conceivably by privately funded, including Helion (needs $20 million for a full-scale reactor, already built a 1/3 scale version) and petawatt picosecond laser fusion (once the lasers get a little better). Another promising approach is levitated dipole, but I don't know what costs look like for that one.
- pippy 14y agoThe sad thing is we've already got the technology for clean(er), cheaper reactors now: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbyr7jZOllI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbyr7jZOllI But we lack the infrastructure and investment to build them.