4 ms·
Some important points on this subject. First, the 1st stage has redundancy against engine failures however the 2nd stage (which uses largely the same engine as
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Some important points on this subject.
First, the 1st stage has redundancy against engine failures however the 2nd stage (which uses largely the same engine as in the 1st stage) has only one engine. So if the per-engine failure rate is too high that could spell bad news for overall vehicle reliability even if the launcher can survive 1st stage engine failures remarkably well. Some reasons to be optimistic: 2nd stage engines have much lower aerodynamic loading and don't have to operate through "max-Q" as the 1st stage engines do (which was incidentally the point in time that the engine failure on this flight happened).
Second, the Falcon 9's 1st stage engines are arranged in a 3x3 grid which seems to result in some unfavorable aerodynamic forces on the engines on the corners. It's possible that this contributed to the engine failure (which occurred in a corner engine) and it's also possible that it contributed to the destruction of the engine fairing after it was shut-down.
Third, the particular engine in use on this vehicle (the Merlin-1C) will only be used on one more flight before being replaced (in the Falcon 9 v1.1) with substantially redesigned Merlin-1D engines (in both the 1st and 2nd stages). Additionally, the engine arrangement on the first stage will change to be octagonal, radially symmetric instead of a grid.
It's good to know the systems and structures to protect against 1st stage engine failure work well, however a lot of the reliability analysis up to this point is somewhat obsoleted by the imminent change in design. I suspect that the engine layout and upgrade will lead to greater overall reliability, but it will take several flights to prove that.
Anyway, some things to chew on.
- jlgreco 14y agoPerhaps also worth mentioning is that the proposed launch abort system is supposed to work at any point of the mission. An engine failure in the second stage would in theory not be a death-sentence to anyone who happens to be riding.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoYes! More so if they have the data and the flight history to show that they can shut down malfunctioning engines before anything worse happens, which raises the survival probabilities of a manned capsule considerably.
- cpeterso 14y ago> the Falcon 9's 1st stage engines are arranged in a 3x3 grid which seems to result in some unfavorable aerodynamic forces on the engines on the corners. Why are the engines arranged in a 3x3 grid instead of something symmetrical like a circle?
- archon 14y agoUninformed guess: They didn't have enough space for anything fancier than a grid pattern. Perhaps the new engines have a smaller footprint.
- hga 14y agoI've read one of the changes in the new engines will be their using their own turbopumps. It's easy to imagine how their previously sourced ones wouldn't allow an internal layout that was optimal for the external layout of the engines.
- eco 14y agoThe Falcon 9 v1.1 will switch to an 8 engines circle with another in the middle layout (as well as using the more powerful Merlin 1D engines). The v1.1 is expected to replace the current v1.0 next year.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoThen again, the probability of failure on the single-engine component is only a ninth the probability of failure on the nine-engine component (assuming there are no other factors, which of course isn't a safe assumption, but I don't know how to adjust).
- shorttime 14y agoHow do you know all of these things? I would like to readup.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]