3 ms·
> Indeed, and the definition of science doesn't contain "must have a unifying theory" as a prerequisite. On the contrary. Crafting and then testing theories is
by lutusp 14y ago
> Indeed, and the definition of science doesn't contain "must have a unifying theory" as a prerequisite.
On the contrary. Crafting and then testing theories is at the heart of how science is defined. A theory is an attempt at explanation, and all scientific theories can be falsified in principle.
No theory, no falsification -- but also, no science.
> Scientific theories may not become true, but science absolutely is a search for truth.
Science is not in any way a search for truth. Truth is not a goal in science, only theories that resist falsification. Any scientific theory is perpetually open to falsification -- that is not a property of truth. Truths aren't falsified later as new facts arrive -- that property is limited to theories.
> I also notice you haven't offered an alternative to my definition, you merely disagreed ("Science is not a search for truth")
No alternative is necessary --the claim is false, period. It's easy to explain why (theories must remain open to falsification by new evidence) but there is no reason to offer an alternative, a replacement.
> and argued against a straw man ("scientific theories never become true").
That wasn't a straw man -- it replies to your claim "Science is anything that searches for the truth in some matter." That is a word-for-word quotation. And it's false -- science's goal is limited to finding evidence to support a theory about reality, prevent it from being falsified.
> and then claimed that this makes mathematics the most pure science there is ...
I never said this, anywhere. Those are not my words.
> I described a way psychology could be scientific, i.e. by experiment.
The topic is not whether psychology cold be scientific, if for example ethical constraints were ignored. The topic is whether psychology is scientific.
> You misrepresent half of my claims and hand-wave the other half.
I misrepresented nothing, instead I quoted you word for word, just as I am doing now. You, by contrast, have invented positions for me, like "... and then claimed that this makes mathematics the most pure science there is ..." as though I had taken that position or used those words.
- StavrosK 14y ago> > Indeed, and the definition of science doesn't contain "must have a unifying theory" as a prerequisite. > On the contrary. Crafting and then testing theories is at the heart of how science is defined. You said: > there is no overarching theory that unites the 53 subfields recognized by the APA I said that there doesn't need to be a unifying theory for a field to be considered a science. "One unifying theory" and "a field united by theories" are two different things. You're misrepresenting my words again, even after quoting them. > Truth is not a goal in science, only theories that resist falsification. Any scientific theory is perpetually open to falsification You seem to think that, since theories can be falsified, they have nothing to do with the truth. This not only doesn't follow, but is false. The truth is that gravity can be modeled with some equations. Newton's theory was pretty close to the truth, Einstein's is even closer. I have no clue how you can say that science doesn't care about the truth and building an accurate model of the world. Phrases like "the map and the territory" come to mind here. > No alternative is necessary --the claim is false, period. So you don't have a definition of science, you only have disagreement to other definitions? That doesn't sound very informed. > It's easy to explain why (theories must remain open to falsification by new evidence) Who said anything about theories being confirmed? If objects fall a certain way, they fall a certain way, some models are more correct than others, even if maybe none are completely correct. Science tries to build as accurate models as it can, getting closer to the actual truth of the world. Where's the problem here? > And it's false -- science's goal is limited to finding evidence to support a theory about reality, prevent it from being falsified. Yes. What you call "reality", I call "truth". > I never said this, anywhere. Those are not my words. Then I misunderstood. You said that my claim that mathematics is not a science was "exactly, precisely, perfectly" wrong. Mathematics isn't a science by your definition or mine. > The topic is not whether psychology cold be scientific, if for example ethical constraints were ignored. The topic is whether psychology is scientific. No, the topic is this claim you made: > I will know psychology as a field has reached the threshold of science when psychologists courageously propose a central, unifying, falsifiable theory, amenable to practical test that, if it fails, invalidates the entire field. I completely disagree. They can have two, three, or a hundred theories like that, and still be a science. The one unified theory isn't special, and that's what I'm arguing. > I misrepresented nothing, instead I quoted you word for word, just as I am doing now. And then misrepresented the meaning of the words you just quoted, as above. > You, by contrast, have invented positions for me, like "... and then claimed that this makes mathematics the most pure science there is ..." as though I had taken that position or used those words. I misunderstood one of your (unfounded) disagreements, hardly an indictment.
- lutusp 14y ago> I said that there doesn't need to be a unifying theory for a field to be considered a science. But that's false. All scientific fields have testable, unifying theories -- single theories that all practitioners agree define their field (even if they plan to falsify the theory) -- and that defines them as practitioners. You name the field, and I will tell you the single, unifying theory that defines the field. Only one requirement -- you have to choose a science, not a pseudoscience. > "One unifying theory" and "a field united by theories" are two different things. Yes -- one describes to the cause, the other describes the effect. Both refer to the requirement that a scientific field be defined by a unifying theory, a theory that makes physics physics, or biology biology. A theory that successfully distinguishes astronomy from astrology. In other words, you're splitting hairs. > You're misrepresenting my words again, even after quoting them. I did nothing of the kind, and I just proved it. > You seem to think that, since theories can be falsified, they have nothing to do with the truth. That is not something I seem to think, that is a fact. Truth cannot be falsified -- that is not how truth is logically defined. A tentative truth is not a truth. A potentially falsifiable truth is not a truth (that's a theory). > The truth is that gravity can be modeled with some equations. This deliberately conflates a statement about gravitational equations with a statement about gravitational theory. If you had instead said "gravity can be accurately modeled with some equations" that would be different -- very different. The first makes a factual statement about an equation, the second makes a theoretical statement about physics. > So you don't have a definition of science, you only have disagreement to other definitions? I defined science based on its requirements, requirements accepted by all scientists and granting agencies. Science is even defined in courts of law at times, as in this example: http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/mclean-v-arkansas.html http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/mclean-v-arkansas.html The above legal ruling, meant to keep Creationism out of the classroom, defines science this way: 1. It is guided by natural law; 2. It has to be explanatory by reference to natural law; 3. It is testable against the empirical world; 4. Its conclusions are tentative, i.e. are not necessarily the final word; and 5. It is falsifiable. So you see, I didn't invent this definition -- it is one on which scientists agree, even those who oppose science on philosophical grounds. >> I never said this, anywhere. Those are not my words. > Then I misunderstood. Misquotations don't arise from misunderstandings, and all such cases can be resolved by using only actual quotations -- by using copy, paste and no creative typing. >> I will know psychology as a field has reached the threshold of science when psychologists courageously propose a central, unifying, falsifiable theory, amenable to practical test that, if it fails, invalidates the entire field. > I completely disagree. They can have two, three, or a hundred theories like that, and still be a science. 1. You just declared astrology a science. Congratulations. By your reasoning, astrology is part of astronomy, differing in only a few theoretical details. But to a scientist, astrology is not astronomy because it has a different theory. 2. Do you know why cellular biology is not particle physics? Different theories. 3. DO you know why particle physics and cosmology are both accepted as part of physics? Same theory. 4. Do you know why physics is accepted as a science? It's because all practitioners of physics, from theoreticians to engineers who build bridges, all agree on the single theory that defines what they do, and that defines physics and distinguishes it from other scientific fields as well as unscientific fields. If a doctor claims that shaking a dried gourd over a cold sufferer will eventually make the patient better, and claims the reason is the gourd treatment, he has crafted a theory, but it's not a medical theory -- it contradicts the prevailing theory that defines medicine. The dried-gourd practitioner is excluded from medicine because his theory doesn't conform to the defining theory of the field. That by itself is sufficient reason to have a single theory (there are other equally important reasons). > And then misrepresented the meaning of the words you just quoted, as above. You failed to make your case. > I misunderstood one of your (unfounded) disagreements, hardly an indictment. Your invented quotation wasn't a misunderstanding, it resulted from your unwillingness to quote only my words directly, using the traditional and undemanding copy, paste meme.