4 ms·
" I believe F9 is the only rocket flying today that, like a modern airliner, is capable of completing a flight successfully even after losing an engine." Brill
by bane 14y ago
" I believe F9 is the only rocket flying today that, like a modern airliner, is capable of completing a flight successfully even after losing an engine."
Brilliant! By equating the rocket with an airliner (the statistically safest way to travel), this turns what could be a mark against into a huge mark for.
- anonymouz 14y agoWhile this is indeed an awesome feature to have, it doesn't by itself mean much. The total reliability of course also depends on the probability that one engine will fail, a rocket that needs all its engines may still be more reliable than one that is capable of of flying with two failed engines, but regularly has to do so. What makes the airliner seem safe is that it can fly with a failed engine and it very rarely loses an engine. I guess we will have to wait for some more flights till we have decent statistics on the reliability of the Falcon 9. Of course, I'm hoping that it will turn out to be an awesome rocket!
- jlgreco 14y agoFor whatever it may be worth, it seems right now the engine failure rate for Falcon 9 is 1 in 27.
- tisme 14y agoIs there a similar rate known for regular jet engines?
- jlgreco 14y agoNo idea. I am sure it is astronomically small though.
- ballooney 14y agoA lot of Western aviation qualifying authorities specify a maximum allowable mean time between failure (MTBF) of 1 per 100000 flight hours. I imagine most rocket engine designs would be more like one per hour! That said, they only have to operate for about ten minutes though before they are disposed of, in the case of expendable launch vehicles. In Falcon 9's case, and totally from memory and probably incorrect and very approximate, we've had 4 launches, each has had 9 Merlin C engines on the first stage, the first stage burn time is 170s or about 3 minutes. There have been two failures - a non destructive engine shutdown on the previous ISS mission on the pad at T-very_little, and the rather more messy rapid disassembly failure of something near the engine or the engine itself on the most recent launch. So, for this first stage engine the MTBF (remember this is all a bit silly and inaccurate and just for ballpark comparisons with the airline industry) the MTBF has been: 9(engines/launch)4(launches)0.05(3 min burns in hours)*0.5(2 failures) = 0.9, i.e. a MTBF of 55 minutes for Merlin 1C lower stage, vs most regulators requiring mtbf > 100000 hours on commercial jet airliner engines. So there's a bit of a way to go yet!
- jlgreco 14y agoAh yes, good stuff. I forgot about the aborted launch, and the initial Falcon 9 launch without Dragon. My 1/27 figure, in addition to being overly simplistic, is wrong.
- DigitalJack 14y agoI agree that there is plenty of room for improvement, but you can't launch a rocket with commercial jet engines. I don't know if it makes sense to normalize for thrust or not, but it seems like thrust should be included somehow.
- saraid216 14y agoThey're not saying, "commercial jet engines are more reliable; therefore we should use them". The issue is that the Merlin 1C engine simply hasn't had enough flights to build up its denominator. It doesn't make sense to normalize for thrust here. This is just failure rate. There's nothing wrong with having a comparatively high failure rate when the sample size is several orders of magnitude smaller: the statistical significance is just weaker; we acknowledge that and move on.