4 ms·
One interesting implication of this work (obvious caveats [1]), those who are more likely to suffer from stereotype thread will underperform those who don't. Th
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
One interesting implication of this work (obvious caveats [1]), those who are more likely to suffer from stereotype thread will underperform those who don't. Thus, even if one measures equal ability among applicants, he should prefer those from a group which is stereotypically superior [2].
An interesting question this raises is how much collectivist attitudes play a role in this effect. For example - consider two hypothetical individuals from a stereotypically underperforming group. Individual A is a collectivist and strongly cares about the perception and welfare of his group. Individual B is an individualist and holds no special affection for his group relative to any other.
Will A be more vulnerable to stereotype thread than B? It's reasonable to hypothesize that individual B might care about stereotypes less than A, and therefore might be less affected.
A fairly straightforward way to test this would be to repeat stereotype threat experiments using dimensions on which people are not typically collectivist (e.g., blood type rather than tribal affiliation).
[1] Assuming the effect survives outside the laboratory, wouldn't necessarily apply in a hypothetical world with different stereotypes, etc.
[2] I'm focusing solely on maximizing group performance, ignoring legal risks, moral issues, etc.
- DaniFong 14y agoUnless outsider membership confers other values, such as perspective or the capacity to make larger out of the box thinking judgements (according to Simonton's research, it does), and unless the degree to which stereotypes undervalue people exceeds the performance gap in the particular situations you can create.
- shenberg 14y agoAs an interesting aside, blood type is actually considered to be a predictor of a person's personality, temperament, etc in Japan - see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_types_in_Japanese_culture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_types_in_Japanese_culture
- stephengillie 14y agoAs is the birth month in European culture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astrology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astrology