4 ms·
Doesn't seem to be the whole story, since the video clearly shows a significant amount of debris. A simple shutdown wouldn't produce debris, although the loss
by ColinWright 14y ago
Doesn't seem to be the whole story, since the video clearly shows a significant amount of debris. A simple shutdown wouldn't produce debris, although the loss of internal pressure on the engine bell could cause it to collapse and possibly disintegrate.
I look forward to seeing a more complete analysis.
- jballanc 14y agoI, too, am looking forward to a full analysis, but I think it helps to recall that this occurred at or near maxQ (maximum dynamic pressure). At these stresses, pretty much anything looks like an "explosion". For example, the Challenger didn't "explode", per se (there was not an ignition as the root cause of failure), but rather "broke up"...though it sure as hell looked like it exploded.
- danielweber 14y agoFrom what I understand, engine exhaust is too hot for any material to withstand without active cooling, which is done as a side-effect of feeding in the fuel. If you just turn it off, then, it's no longer actively cooled, and will rapidly melt from all the other engines around it still going full bore. This is just a theory.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThe engine exhaust is very highly directional, it doesn't just go everywhere. For example, the supporting structures around the engines are exposed to the same level of exhaust as a shut-down engine would be, and they are completely uncooled.