23 ms·
> Results of failure are still results Yes! I would add that failing to replicate existing results is the only interesting outcome of a replicating study. If
by bambax 14y ago
> Results of failure are still results
Yes! I would add that failing to replicate existing results is the only interesting outcome of a replicating study.
If we try to replicate a study and arrive at the same conclusions, we have learned little (the original result is a little stronger but that's about it).
If however, a series of new studies fail to replicate original results, we have learned a lot -- we have learned that those original results were false.
I think the whole problem is, ironically, psychological in nature. Results of studies become articles of faith; people identify with their beliefs and hate to admit they have been fooled...
- StavrosK 14y ago> Results of studies become articles of faith; people identify with their beliefs and hate to admit they have been fooled... Exactly, and that's precisely the opposite of what science is. We should be excited, not intimidated, by falsifications and getting results we didn't expect.