3 ms·
You're missing an important structural difference between psychology and truly scientific fields like physics. The difference is that scientific fields are unit
by lutusp 14y ago
You're missing an important structural difference between psychology and truly scientific fields like physics. The difference is that scientific fields are united by theories that define the entire the field, and that inform all work in the field.
If a particle physicist discovers something basic in his own specialty, it affects all of physics -- for example, the mass of neutrinos or the presence or absence of a Higgs boson. Cosmologists must pay attention to particle physics, even though particle physics and cosmology would seem to be spectacularly dissimilar.
Such a scientific theory is a two-way street. If cosmology comes up with something like dark matter or dark energy, based on solid observation but not explained, this affects particle physics, and work begins immediately to explain what has only been described. The reason is that the central scientific theory, that defines physics, also unites it.
Psychology doesn't have such a theory -- there is no overarching theory that unites the 53 subfields recognized by the APA, which consequently operate independently of each other and of any serious concern about theoretical implications.
So when you say that there is real science taking place in some of psychology's subfields, you're absolutely right. But if someone wants to imply that this means psychology is a science in the same way that physics or biology are sciences, they're absolutely wrong.
> to dismiss all of psychological science as illegitimate is to ignore a tremendous amount of progress in understanding and human well-being that has come in the past century.
When Michelson and Morley falsified the ether theory in 1887, every living physicist knew exactly what that result meant -- it pulled the rug from under electromagnetic theory and left it unexplained. No one tried to say, "but those other physicists are still doing good work." That's not how science works.
I will know psychology as a field has reached the threshold of science when psychologists courageously propose a central, unifying, falsifiable theory, amenable to practical test that, if it fails, invalidates the entire field. And I won't hold my breath for that development.
Physics has such a theory. Biology has such a theory. Geology has one. Any of those theories can be tested -- indeed, is regularly tested --and the failure to falsify those theories is the only reason for the standing of those fields as sciences.
Science is not scientists working in isolation, in a theoretical vacuum, on studies that cannot be replicated, as with psychology. Science is instead the building of a defining theoretical structure, constructed on a scaffolding of evidence.
> and human well-being that has come in the past century.
That claim is completely falsified by the recovered memory therapy debacle of the 1990s, which singlehandedly erased any public goodwill toward the field of psychology and sowed an atmosphere of distrust that will require many years to dissipate. And recovered memory therapy is just one of many examples in recent times that reveal the danger of not shaping a guiding theory that simultaneously informs research and controls the behavior of clinicians.
- StavrosK 14y agoMy definition is different from yours. Science is anything that searches for the truth in some matter. For example, math isn't a science, because it isn't searching for any truths. It's building tools by following sets of rules. Psychology can be about discovering the truth about people's minds on a high level, so it can be a science. It probably hasn't been going about it the right way so far, though. I think most of the field is sitting around theorizing (like the Greek philosophers) rather than come up with testable claims.
- lutusp 14y ago> My definition is different from yours. We don't get to pick any definition of science we like. Science is by definition an agreement between people, a consensus about what evidence means, what falsifiability means, and finally what science itself means. Everything else is post-modernism. > Science is anything that searches for the truth in some matter. That is precisely not how science is defined. Science is not a search for truth, and scientific theories never become true. Some become false, none become true, ever. All scientific theories are perpetually open to falsification by new evidence. > For example, math isn't a science, because it isn't searching for any truths. You just picked the only science that violates the general rule, that is able establish something as true, beyond falsification. So your claim about mathematics is exactly, precisely -- perfectly -- wrong. > Psychology can be about discovering the truth about people's minds on a high level, so it can be a science. You've just described religion, but science isn't religion. Science is based on skepticism and doubt, not on a mystical search for truth.
- StavrosK 14y ago> We don't get to pick any definition of science we like. Indeed, and the definition of science doesn't contain "must have a unifying theory" as a prerequisite. > Science is not a search for truth, and scientific theories never become true. Scientific theories may not become true, but science absolutely is a search for truth. There is a truth, and we're trying to get to it with rational means. I also notice you haven't offered an alternative to my definition, you merely disagreed ("Science is not a search for truth") and argued against a straw man ("scientific theories never become true"). > So your claim about mathematics is exactly, precisely -- perfectly -- wrong. How so? You just said that mathematics is a science that violates the general rule, even the definition you hint to (falsifiability), and then claimed that this makes mathematics the most pure science there is ("your claim about mathematics is exactly, precisely -- perfectly -- wrong"). > You've just described religion, but science isn't religion. No, I didn't. I described a way psychology could be scientific, i.e. by experiment. You misrepresent half of my claims and hand-wave the other half. I didn't expect you, of all people, to do that.