4 ms·
What makes you think that the US Constitution is working as planned without regulatory capture? The purpose of the Constitution is to provide for a working fed
by btilly 14y ago
What makes you think that the US Constitution is working as planned without regulatory capture?
The purpose of the Constitution is to provide for a working federal government, but to limit the scope and power of that government as much as possible. But does it seem to you that the scope of the government has actually been limited as intended?
The problem is that all three branches gain when you increase the scope and power of government. Therefore there is a small but consistent error on the side of expanding the government among all three groups. The result is a government that is far larger than anything that the Founders envisioned. Individually we may or may not think that this is a good change, but there is no question that it is not as intended by the original Constitution.
The place that you can see this most clearly is in the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Clause http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Clause. This gives Congress the power To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian tribes.
Until the 1930s, this was interpreted as written. If an act of commerce didn't involve Indian tribes, multiple states, or foreign governments, then Congress couldn't justify laws about it under the Commerce Clause. Then FDR wanted to pass the New Deal. The courts struck down key provisions. FDR threatened to appoint pliant judges until he got what he wanted. A key vote switched, FDR got the decision he wanted, and the Commerce Clause began to expand to cover any activity that might possibly, some day, affect interstate commerce. No matter how tangentially.
We went from, "If it doesn't cross a boundary, Congress can't say anything" to "Even if you, your business, your employees, and most of your likely customers all exist in one state, Congress can still pass regulations about who you can hire." (Yes, I like the Civil Rights Act. I'm just saying that it would not be constitutional under the Constitution as understood by Thomas Jefferson.)
From the first strong-arming of the Supreme Court to the next decision where the Commerce Clause was not upheld to cover whatever Congress asked for it to cover took 60 years. (The Court finally hit its limit with an attempt to regulate the possession of handguns in the neighborhood of a school.) Every expansive decision increased the scope of what the President could ask for, Congress could pass, and the potential impact of the corresponding cases that the Supreme Court had to judge.
- specialist 14y agoWorking as planned? I wouldn't know. I'm not talking about the pathology of the USA govt. What I'm trying to do is talk about systems more resistant to regulatory capture. What marvels me is the three-way fight. It just seems much more self-balancing. And great things happen when people have to hash things out. Back when I was a product manager, I structured the team to mimic the balance of powers. (That particular company was engineering dominated, which got fairly pathological.) Marketing was in charge of price and scope. Engineering was in charge of cost and schedule. QA was in charge of testing and shipping. Give and take. Creative tension. The outcome was brilliant. After a storming period, the team settled into a tempo and always made our dates and sales numbers. I don't know if setting up a three-way fight is a repeatable organizational structure. But it's the best idea I've come across to date. The only other idea I have is increased transparency. (PS- All big decision were made democratically, with various kinds of voting systems. eg Go/NoGo was roman evaluation, triage was risk management style, etc.)
- Evbn 14y agoNo matter how many powers balance, if humans are able to move from government to private sector, regulatory capture will happen. How can a system prevent that?
- specialist 14y agoGreat question. I don't know. Public v private is a two-way fight. On my product team, I gave QA a seat at the table, creating a three-way fight. Since I don't have any original notions of my own, I'm watching out for ideas, experiments, alternatives, supplements to public v private. The only notion I've got is public v private v citizen. By citizen, I roughly mean open government, transparency, accountability. I've been VERY politically involved. In my spare time, I'm trying to make tools to better empower future citizen activists. Maybe level the playing field a bit.