5 ms·
I would hardly call that excessive profanity. In a 2000+ word article there are what, 10 instances of 'profanity'? Honestly I think it speaks more to your mat
by jlgreco 14y ago
I would hardly call that excessive profanity. In a 2000+ word article there are what, 10 instances of 'profanity'?
Honestly I think it speaks more to your maturity that you would find that so bothering that it could detract from the content of the article.
- sigzero 14y agoThen he and I both lack maturity. So be it. I find the complaint valid.
- freditup 14y agoHonestly, I think it speaks more to your maturity that you are so bothered that people are bothered by profanity. In all seriousness though, profanity is unprofessional. I think a fair definition of profanity is 'vulgar extreme emotion.' If you have to use 'extreme emotion' to get your point across, then you aren't doing it right. You should be able to describe something or explain something with some sort of levelheadedness. On to the 'vulgar' part. We can fairly say that some people could care less about vulgarity and others are bothered by it. So why put it in in the first place? I'm not saying we all have to be ultra politically correct, but if I'm giving a speech on the free market, I'm not going to insert snide comments about liberal politicians and their economic beliefs. I could, it might even make sense in context, but there's no reason to.
- jlgreco 14y ago"profanity is unprofessional" That I can agree with. It is signals more of a casual tone than a professional tone. Why should someone use a casual tone instead of a professional tone? Why not? It is nothing more than individual preference. Write in the style you feel most comfortable with. ("Honestly, I think it speaks more to your maturity that you are so bothered that people are bothered by profanity." That he is bothered is not what makes me think he lacks maturity. That he is bothered to such a degree that he thinks those particular words actually devalue the article itself is what I think signals immaturity. The ability to separate ones emotional response to something from their intellectual appreciation of something is a hallmark of maturity.)
- PommeDeTerre 14y agoI don't take offense to the words that were used. It's more akin to articles that use absurd fonts or blatantly poor color schemes. Such things are unnecessary, and make it more awkward to absorb the actual content. When I see authors doing things that obviously make their work harder to read, it does make me question their judgment, which in turn makes me question the validity of what is being expressed.
- jlgreco 14y agoTo be clear, I am not criticizing you for finding certain words to be offensive or thinking that they are offensive words. I am criticizing you for questioning the validity of the article because the author used certain words that you find/think are offensive. I mean seriously...
- mercurial 14y agoI pretty much agree with you, though it certainly depends on the context (I'm more likely to not be bothered by it in a post on a mailing list). But for a technical writeup? You want to be treated like a professional, write like one.