5 ms·
Will Android Tablets Overtake the iPad?
- gmoore 14y agoprobably
- koffiezet 14y agoDoubt it. If as rumored, Apple releases an iPad 'mini', I think this is going to be an iPod situation, where the iPad grabs the majority of the market, with a lot of smaller manufacturers picking up the bits. The thing is, Android phones were pushed by carriers. For tablets, this hardly happens, although I've seen "free tablet" promotions when getting a new internet connection, but that has hardly done anything as far as I know. The Kindle fire might be a contender, but I don't really see that as a real competitor, and that's hardly Android. The software quality also seems to be very low to me. And then you have Microsoft, who is making the same mistakes they made the first time they attempted a tablet. They will maybe sell a few, but if the sales of the 'ultrabooks' are a good indication, expensive tablets running Windows 8 won't be the success they're hoping for. I know dozens of people having an iPad, including complete non-techies - and they love it. I know 1 guy with an Asus transformer, and 1 with a Galaxy tab 10", both IT guys. The Asus's build quality surprised me in the positive way, the galaxy tab in a negative way. In both cases, I thought the software was useless, and web-browsing slow and sluggish compared to my iPad 2. That said, the moment I can order a Nexus 7 here in Belgium, I'm getting one.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> I know 1 guy with an Asus transformer I don't know why people are making such a big deal about Samsung tablets and Kindle Fires but completely ignoring the Asus Transformer line. The Asus Transformer Pad Infinity is an amazing tablet with good hardware that runs stock Jelly Bean. I've had a Transformer Prime for almost a year and it's been a great device, but it's like no one has even heard of it. It's a really weird situation, perhaps caused by a lack of advertising (much like the Galaxy Nexus).
- manojlds 14y agoNah, people were going crazy about the Prime pre-launch. And Asus messed it up with delays and poor WiFi, non-existant GPS and then srewing customers who did buy it by announcing "better" model soon after.
- w1ntermute 14y agoI kept hearing about these issues, but never saw them myself. Maybe those people having the issues were holding the tablet wrong? Besides, the Transformer Pad Infinity hasn't had these issues, has it?
- bergie 14y agoI didn't have any major problems with the Transformer Prime. GPS on that big tablet is pretty much useless anyway, and the battery life given my the keyboard was awesome on conference trips. Here is a liveblog I wrote with vim on the Prime: http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/symfony-live/ http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/symfony-live/ I even had a Ubuntu chroot on the machine for Node.js projects, and if the keyboard hadn't been so bad that could be now my primary computer. Instead, I switched it to Nexus 7 and again do any longer writing on my 11" MBA...
- StavrosK 14y agoI don't know, I bought one months ago and I love it to bits. It's the best tablet I've ever owned, hands down, and I used to have an iPad before.
- enraged_camel 14y agoNot only is iPad popular, it also has an incredible amount of market penetration in a large variety of industries. You have airlines talking about giving their pilots iPads, you have schools giving their teachers and even students iPads for classroom learning, you have car manufacturers designing iPad docks for their cars with integrated controls... it is extremely unlikely that a competitor is going to be able to dislodge Apple from their leadership position anytime soon. If I were an Apple competitor, I'd forget about tablets and smartphones and invest all my resources into developing the next "big thing". The reason is simple: Apple cannot be beat in its own game. So the smart thing to do is to innovate a new revolutionary device, something that will create its own category. I'd say that the only tech company who has the potential for a feat of this magnitude is Google. However, even they seem to lack focus. That's one huge advantage that Apple had: Steve Jobs' extraordinary focus and vision. If you look at Google, you see that they are working on cool projects like self-driving cars and Google Glass, but what they need is a technology that converges these inventions in one physical device. And that's possible only with a visionary who will set a clear and ambitious direction for all the various product teams at Google.
- bdcravens 14y agoI think there's a ton of room at the bottom. There was a time when DVD players and home computers were out of the reach of the poor or lower middle class. Most (responsible) people can't afford a $500+ tablet, but the promise of tablet computing still applies to them. It's a lie to say that the promise of tablet computing can only be accomplished in a $500+ package. There's tons of room for tablets that are $250 or less - see all the "low end" phone providers that now have Android offerings.
- enraged_camel 14y agoThere's room at the bottom in terms of market share, but not in terms of profits. Android has captured a bigger chunk of the market, but Apple is reaping most of the profits (since their devices are high margin) and is therefore in a much better position to innovate or leap on opportunities that come up. I mean, who wouldn't want to sit on a $120+ billion warchest? What's going to be really interesting is when (if) the "iPad Mini" comes out. There was an article on Ars Technica last month where a reputable analyst claimed Apple found a way to manufacture iPad Minis with the last generation iPad's components. What that means is that even at $250, the device would be extremely high margin. Not only would it allow Apple to lock down the lower market segment, but also result in a huge increase in profits. From a business standpoint it seems like a no-brainer, because a cheap and yet high margin device is not something that other manufacturers can imitate.
- myspy 14y agoDoubt it too. What underwhelms me the most are the apps/general software. I have a Nexus 7 and I don't really know what to do with it anymore. I played around with it a lot, and put some emulators on it, but having to go back to a file browser for reading a book or putting on music is giving me a PC feeling, and I don't really want a tablet to feel like a PC. Furthermore, it's no fun to do web browsing, because the browser has very small touch targets and I have to take a lot of steps accessing my bookmarks I sync via Chrome for Mac. Listening to music is bad. The player software sucks, it lacks any finish and small subtle things I like on the iOS version. And the headphone jack delivers bad sound quality. Apps are generally blown up phone versions. The bigger screen is not really used. I don't like the software buttons, they tempt me to get accidentally touched. I would prefer a physical button. And another mild annoyance is the button to switch it on, which is on the site and I very often touch it when trying to make it louder. Also you always have to touch that small button instead of having a button under the screen to activate the device which is very slow. When you have kids, get them an iPad, especially with the "boring" grid layout of icons, its easier for them to access apps. And they stay in a app, without touching one of the always on software buttons. Maybe my general problem is, I don't want to use Googles ecosystem. I don't think it's very likable. For instance the music app. For Google it's something they put on there, because you need it, but they put no real effort behind it. From Apple I get the impression, people are working on it, who want to achieve a great music listening experience. It's the same with buying content. I don't really feel it at Google. It caters more to the nerd, where is the humanity? This should not prevent you from getting one. But I very much doubt that an Android tablet is as useful for the average user as an iPad and therefore gaining as much market share. Maybe Amazon will find a way to gain marketshare with their ecosystem, but the software appears to suck. And Microsoft, they will struggle first to get decent applications for their tablets, and who will do RT software, when the full desktop version could be right around the corner? The Nexus 7, I handed it over to my wife, she uses it as an e-reader, the screen is great for that. Personally I'm looking forward to a smaller iPad 3 or iPad mini. Maybe a Surface in the near future.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoI see tablets and PCs merging more in the future, as the current trends indicate. Tablets will become smarter, PCs dumber. They'll meet somewhere in the middle. That being the case, the market is too big, and too important, to have 1 single hardware/software vendor dominate it in the way iPod dominated the music player market. The iPod's dominance had a negative effect on that market; it effectively killed it. And once Apple found something more profitable, they stopped innovating on it as well.
- bergie 14y agoI wrote something about this in http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/tablet-productivity/ http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/tablet-productivity/ Basically I see the culture (especially in business apps and communication) slowly adapt to tablets and smartphones, instead of them converging with text-based PC ideas
- adestefan 14y agoIf the iPad mini rumors end up being true, I'll sell my Nexus 7 for the iPad mini. I've had a terrible experience with both the hardware and tablet versions of Android apps. I'd be happy to get $100 out of my Nexus 7 that's how unhappy I've been.
- robocat 14y agoIf you are happy to ship to New Zealand I am keen (Nexus 7 is expensive here). I already bought one second hand for my brother but I want one for myself (now I found out I love Nexus 7 more than an iPad!) c d r c a t A T g m a i l . c o m PS: This thread already removed from HN, so hopefully it is OK that I am adding irrelevant comment noise?
- sgt 14y agoAndroid may overtake iPad or not - what are the real implications of this? I think it'll stabilize at some point where either iPad has a little more market share or little less. Practically it doesn't really matter much. The iOS ecosystem will still thrive, and I personally I think a bit of healthy competition is exactly what we need to push the tablet world forward.
- protomyth 14y agoIf the iPad mini (or whatever it is actually going to be called) comes out at $199, that takes a lot of room out of the bottom of the market. If it is $249 or $299, then the Fire and other have some space to play in.
- stcredzero 14y agoI think Apple's strategy here is to keep the price pressure on for the bottom end of the market. Since their margins are better than everyone else's, they can give up some of that to deliver a 7" tablet that keeps the competitors in the low price ghetto, struggling to compete, while Apple makes $$ in the high end.
- zabraxias 14y agoI absolutely agree but I am guessing a price tag of $300 which wouldn't quite achieve keeping the competition at bay.
- protomyth 14y agoIf they repeat their iPod strategy, then $199 is the 7" price point. I agree, $299 is not going to put the pricing pressure on the low-end.
- stcredzero 14y agoSo, the Shuffle was to put pressure on the low end of the market? If they can sell a tablet for $199 and still make $30 profit, they can put a heck of a lot of price pressure on competitors.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoDue to subsidies, there's a lot more room at the bottom in tablets. You can get an iPhone for $99, if you sign a contract, so to be much "cheaper" than that the difference is a subtle one based on contract terms. If the next nexus is $100 as rumored that puts it into impulse buy territory for most westerners.
- buster 14y agoSure it will. Everyone who says no is (in my oppinion) trapped in the famous Apple Reality Distortion Field(tm) ;) It's the same situation as with the iPhone. People said "noooo, the iPhone will be king ever!!". Nope. Honestly, how could this even happen? With one tablet? Or 2? Where is the diversity? Where is the low-cost option? Where is my tablet with keyboard attached? Etc. etc. Android is about choice, it will win this, undoubtly. As long as Apple doesn't produce much more different hardware and delivers at much more price points, they will not win the whole market. But well. There is always the high margin top niche ;)
- stcredzero 14y ago> Where is the diversity? Where is the low-cost option? Right now there's the choice of the iPad 2, or "The New iPad" and soon we can add the "iPad Mini." > Where is my tablet with keyboard attached? Etc. etc. Logitech makes a really slick one. http://www.logitech.com/en-us/tablet-accessories/keyboard-cases/ultrathin-keyboard-cover http://www.logitech.com/en-us/tablet-accessories/keyboard-ca...
- buster 14y agoNo, seriously. There is one iPad, not the new one and the old one. So soon, there will be 2 ipads, virtually the same devices with different screen sizes. But people want choice. I'm not sure if this is different in the US or wherever you come from but it's frightening how many women i know who choose their phones based on the color(!). Then there are people only buying phones with hardware keyboards, some which want it slide-out some on front. Then there are students that buy the lowcost variants of android gadgets, etc. In all: There will never be "the one device everyone wants". No. No. No. Saying otherwise is just ignorant.
- threedaymonk 14y ago> it's frightening how many women i know who choose their phones based on the color(!). I don't know why that's frightening. For many people, almost any current smart phone will meet their communication requirements, so why shouldn't they choose the one that they like the look of? It's no stranger than buying a watch on style rather than the accuracy of its stopwatch or purported ability to work at the bottom of the Mariana Trench.
- wutbrodo 14y agoI believe these figures were pre-Nexus 7 (and pre Kindle Fire HD line), so all else held equal, I'd imagine these figures are skewed slightly downwards.
- RexRollman 14y agoI could see it happen, especially if you count things like the Nook and Kindle Touch as Android tablets.
- tomjen3 14y agoWhy not? It happened with the I phone, and the PC when it took over the market (although Apple wasn't as dominant back then).
- onedev 14y agoNo. (as per Betteridge's law)
- jarcoal 14y agoVolume? Almost certainly. Profit? No chance.
- tsieling 14y agoLikely, so long as the definition of an Android tablet stays stretchy and flexible: does it need Google's seal of approval? does it need to be upgradeable to subsequent official Android releases? does it just need to have started with Android? There's no solid definition, so we end up trying to compare one product from one company against a spectrum of design and build approaches (and quality levels) and boil it down to a coherent horse race. No wonder the numbers from different tracking points are out of whack.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sksksk 14y agoHow come people don't consider ebooks as competitors to the tablets? I had a first generation iPad, and I did use it a lot. Then I got a notebook computer to replace my desktop, and started using that more. I pretty much only used my iPad while commuting, and then made an impulse purchase and got a Kindle. I find I use my Kindle all the time, and haven't touched the iPad for over a year now. As a device that sits between a phone and a notebook/desktop, I think ebook readers are viable competition to tablets
- bdcravens 14y agoSure. Most responsible lower-middle class or poor families can't afford an iPad, but something in the $99-300 range is doable. This is the trajectory that smart phones went: I see tons of people with Android Crickets. As others have pointed out, this should have no bearing on Apple's success: I've never met someone who wanted a MacBook Pro who changed their mind because of a $299 laptop at WalMart.
- josteink 14y agoMost responsible lower-middle class or poor families can't afford an iPad That statement makes no sense. Everyone and their grandma can have an iPad. They are being given away for "free", bundled with 3G subscriptions. Android tablets you actually have to buy. Where I live, Android-tablets are mostly found among wealthier, informed people.
- bdcravens 14y agoMy other take: no. Highly customized Android tablets will (Kindle Fires and Nook tablets). Most users don't root them; they use them as the walled gardens they're designed to be. Pure Android devices will continue to be a minority. (OP's article suggests this, with Fire's at 50% of "Android" tablet market) To me, a Kindle Fire is as much an "Android" tablet as a Nexus 7 is a "Linux" tablet.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoI don't think Fred Wilson's point was that they all use a common interface. Being a VC, I'm guessing the app compatibility is the thing he cares about.
- webreac 14y agoWithout rooting, you already have more freedom with android: you can install any application outside of google market.
- jfb 14y agoAlmost certainly, if by "overtake" one means "sells more units" and Android means "is built on a fork of Android". Apple will likely continue to capture the overwhelming share of profit.
- habosa 14y agoYes, they may have already done so. Recent reports show Android with 48% of market share WITHOUT counting Nexus 7 or Kindle Fire HD/Nook Tablet HD sales. I'd say those will easily cover the missing 2%.
- flyinglizard 14y agoAll I know is that after having the Nexus 7, the iPad (3, which I also have) feels like a burden to use. Slower, double the weight, not nearly as portable and iOS feels byzantine next to Jelly Bean. My friends universally share my sentiments. Apple market share will fall over time to 20%-30%. You can't cater to all users with a single product, and they don't bring enough innovation to make their product a must-have.
- robocat 14y agoThe question is too coarse. In which markets will Android tablets overtake iPads? In which markets do Android tablets already outsell iPads?
- robocat 14y agoThis article has 3 graphs (for mobile phone market) that are very relevant to tablets as well: http://www.asymco.com/2012/05/03/the-phone-market-in-2012-a-tale-of-two-disruptions/ http://www.asymco.com/2012/05/03/the-phone-market-in-2012-a-... Does "crossing the chasm" apply to the tablet market? Massive sales of cheap tablets/phablets in countries where iPad's are grossly unaffordable (price of a Rolex is US equivalent) will generate companies that can eat Apple's pie. It will take years, but it has already happened (Korea and China), and is happening in non-US markets.
- robocat 14y agoOops correction - Koreans buy iPads (70% to 80% market share in Q2).