7 ms·
Robert Bork on antitrust: Google is no Microsoft
- 001sky 14y agoHe said that Google had "commissioned" the study but the views expressed it it were solely his and Bork's. (Because of health reasons, Bork didn't attend today's AEI event.) -- In case anyone was wondering. Not that there's anything wrong with that. Still Interesting.
- ams6110 14y agoResearch is always funded by someone. Nothing is truly unbiased or without hidden agendas.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI have a hard time understanding how this can be considered an antitrust violation when switching is so easy and there is so much competition in the space. While a company should be held accountable for harming consumers, it should be held accountable for stupid consumers. I really don't like how Google is including all the links to their own properties inside of their searches. In fact, I like it so little that I pipe most of my searches through DDG now. Yet I still wind up at Google around 20% of the time when I'm searching for terms with many matches. Google gets the ordering better. It is scary to think what might happen if Google is found to be violating antitrust laws.
- ams6110 14y agoIndeed, there are dozens of choices for web browsers, and even if you limit yourself to "mainstream" browsers there are still close to half-a-dozen. Likewise search, and there's nothing other than quality of results limiting any of them (i.e. using Chrome as a browser doesn't prevent you from using DDG or Bing for search, or even make it difficult).
- nivla 14y ago>I have a hard time understanding how this can be considered an antitrust violation when switching is so easy. Switching was never hard even in Microsoft's anti-trust case. You could easily download and install Netscape. Microsoft never forbid anyone from doing it and I can remember distinctly Netscape being included with my ISP's software floppy. What made the case was all about what was available default to the user. Interestingly under the same context you will find anti-trust violations if Chromebook became the majority and Firefox din't come installed by default.
- azylman 14y agoIt doesn't matter how hard switching is for the browser, what matters is how hard switching was for the OS - that's where Microsoft had a monopoly. In that, switching was very hard. They were trying to leverage that monopoly in a new market (browsers).
- 001sky 14y agoThe key point. SW online does not have the charachteristics of natural monopoly. I have 8x choices in my integrated search bar (the default ones on Firefox). There are some network effects, or returns to scale from usage analytics that impact quality, but that is a different animal. MS Dos / Intel x86 technical architecture was actually exclusive. Also, with MSFT was clearly a case of prediatory pricing funded by cross-subsidy from the monoply business. They set out to 'kill' netscape in its infacy as a business stratgy. Google is arguably just doing its job, and doing it better. Advertisers fell like there is "no choice" (because of scale), but they are sock-puppets. The consumer is the searcher. Advertisers have plenty of other places to advertsise online, so there is no monopoly.
- dbaupp 14y ago"Yet I still wind up at Google around 20% of the time when I'm searching for terms with many matches" I'm the same, and, unfortunately, even more often when searching for terms with very few matches. Google actually finds the relevant things.
- fleitz 14y agoCertainly not, Google learned from Microsoft that without friends in Washington to make these problems go away, they'll charge you with random offenses until you start contributing to their campaigns. "That's a nice business over there, would be a shame if we found you were running a monopoly, why don't you contribute to our campaign and we'll protect you from those DOJ lawyers" If giving a browser away is anti-competitive I wonder what giving an entire operating system + browser away for free is.
- mikeash 14y agoPeople seem to forget that Microsoft was targeted because of its anticompetitive tactics as a monopoly. At its peak, MS had something like 95% of the market for PC operating systems, and was busily using that monopoly to push its way into other markets where it wouldn't necessarily be competitive on its own. The problem wasn't giving away IE, the problem was giving away IE with their OS so that they could take over the browser market by leveraging their OS monopoly. Until and unless Google (or any other modern player) has a 90+% market share in some area, comparisons with MS's antitrust case are faulty.
- ams6110 14y agoAnd I never saw it this way... IE was legitimately better than Netscape for a while, and consumers gravitated to it. As proof, IE is still the default browser, and Windows is still the dominant PC OS, but IE has fallen from its top position because competing browsers are better. Microsoft's so-called "monopoly" on the desktop did not prevent competition; you could always easily install a different browser, and now that the alternatives are better than IE, people are doing that.
- code_duck 14y agoSo, when Microsoft execs were talking about choking Netscape and 'cutting off their air supply', they meant by making a better browser, you're saying?
- 14y ago
- joshuaheard 14y agoThe Clinton administrations anti-trust judgment against Microsoft burst the internet bubble and sent our economy into a recession, the effects of which we are still feeling. It also shackled Microsoft for 10 years as part of the judgment, so they have been unable to effectively compete with Google and Apple. This year, that 10 year judgment agreement ended, so expect to see more from Micrsoft.
- adgar2 14y agoI've never heard this argument before. Why was Microsoft owning the desktop and browser market so fundamental to the US economy?
- zxcdw 14y agoThey weren't. Computers and Internet became a commodity so the market was overcrowded and overhyped. Once the realization happened, the market plummeted and tons of investment and effort went down the drain. People went batshit insane over the internet in a few years, invested tons and tons and it all collapsed.
- joshuaheard 14y agoThe PC and internet fuled the productivity gains of the nineties. If you look at the timing, the stock market crashed a couple of months after the ruling came out. Up until that time, the internet was the wild west. With the Microsoft judgment, it became clear to the market that the internet would be subject to regular rules. The stock market plays off such psychological factors. Also, Microsoft was the biggest player back then so it was a blow to the entire industry. People were wondering if the interet boom was a speculative bubble, and the ruling was the pin that popped it.
- DanielBMarkham 14y ago"Given the serious factual, logical, and economic flaws in the antitrust complaints about Google's practices, one can reasonably conclude only that Google's competitors are seeking to use antitrust law to protect their own market positions." Translation: the technology industry learns fast. If you want to be a big player, be prepared to play hardball.
- yuhong 14y agoPersonally, my favorite from the 90s is the MS OS/2 2.0 fiasco I discussed before.
- overbroad 14y agoMaybe Apple is the new Microsoft, not Google? Maybe Apple does not have as many potential competitors i.e. virtually anyone selling ad space, to raise complaints?
- capo 14y agoI'm no lawyer but logically speaking the antitrust allegations against Google don't seem like they'll amount to much, firstly the notion of having the government dictate what goes in your app/website doesn't sound right nor legal. And there is the blatantly self serving demands from competitor alleging consumer harm; they either want to be guaranteed prominent placement among Google’s results or they want Google to only feature links, and only links to the end of time, meaning they don't want them to innovate and would like them to offer an inferior product, and given that people have had a taste of Siri for example, the notion that search engines must only serve links has dissipated. There is also the small detail of Google being free, and has virtually no-lockin and anything they offer has an equivalent offered by somebody else. And last time I checked they didn't lack in competitors, so why is the government essentially also competing against Google. The whole thing seems like a result of a major political malfunction.
- nugget 14y agoSorry but you don't seem to understand how antitrust law works. Today, in the US and many other parts of the world, Google has a monopoly in the search market. Google is using their monopoly in that market to influence a second market (any one of a number of content verticals). It doesn't matter whether the service is free, or not free. Influence and unfair competition - this is the definition of antitrust. (How can any SEO or SEM expert ever compete against Google itself for search rankings or ad placements? They can't.) Microsoft tried to use its monopoly in OS to influence browser choice, and was rightly persecuted for it; this case is not much different.
- fkdjs 14y agoIn the US at least, you must prove that the consumer was harmed in order to have a successful antitrust complaint, and that's going to be pretty hard with google. With microsoft, it was a pretty clear pattern, ie rebates to OEMs to thwart competition. And more recently, disallowing users to change their default browser. Instead, with google, you can bid/get ranked high and you're still able to compete. You can install chrome and change the default search engine easily, etc etc. Google has been pretty careful about avoiding mistakes Microsoft made. And at the end of the day, if you don't like google, you type in "bing.com" and lo and behold, you're using another search engine. You could not (at the time at least)just install a competing OS within seconds.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> Google had "commissioned" the study but the views expressed it it were solely his and Bork's I agree with the notion that Google is fundamentally different to Microsoft, but I don't understand why reputable people, presumably without any financial need to do so, take money that would give them an appearance of bias on an issue. I'm not saying either Google or Bork did anything wrong here per se. But I know if I had a reputation to protect, I wouldn't do it, because it would color how people perceived me in the future. I would get both sides to fund it or none of them.
- DrHankPym 14y agoReason why Google is no Microsoft monopoly: no copyright enforcement. Microsoft depended on the government's ability to help enforce copyright protection, thus the government sponsored its monopoly. If Google went off suing all its users then I bet the government would care more.