3 ms·
Well structured monoliths are modularized just like microservices. No need to give each module its own REST API in order to keep it clean.
by manmal 11mo ago
Well structured monoliths are modularized just like microservices. No need to give each module its own REST API in order to keep it clean.
- Yoric 11mo agoI guess that the benefit of monoliths in the context is that they (often) live in distinct repositories, which makes it easier for Claude to ingest them entirely, or at least not get lost into looking at the wrong directory.
- bccdee 11mo agoConversely, poorly-structured microservices are just monoliths where most of the code is in other repositories.
- randomtoast 11mo agoOne problem is that the idea of being "well-structured" has gone overboard at some point over the past 20 years in many companies. As a result, many companies now operate highly convoluted monolithic systems that are extremely difficult to replace. In contrast, a poorly designed microservice can be replaced much more easily. You can identify the worst-performing and most problematic microservices and replace them selectively.
- tuhgdetzhh 11mo ago> One problem is that the idea of being "well-structured" has gone overboard at some point over the past 20 years That's exactly my experience. While a well-structured monolith is a good idea in theory, and I'm sure such examples exist in practice, that has never been the case in any of my jobs. Friends working at other companies report similar experiences.