5 ms·

I'm sorry, but did you ask ChatGPT or another LLM to critique this article?

• ericmcer 11mo ago
  definitely reads like it... what is the point lol? Can you sell HN accounts or something?
  • nelox 11mo ago
    The point was simply to analyse the argument on its merits
    • cyanydeez 11mo ago
      By word salad, ?
• nelox 11mo ago
  It was a straightforward critique of the article’s claims
  • cyanydeez 11mo ago
    That does...answer tge question?
    • nelox 11mo ago
      not an attempt to pass off anything as my own
      • hogepiyo 11mo ago
        then stop wasting peoples time with slop if i wanted to read llm output i'd go dump it into chatgpt into myself
        • nelox 11mo ago
          Do I need to explain the meaning of not?
          • minimaxir 11mo ago
            Your AI generated summaries have been repeatedly flagged by HN users. They do not add value to the discussion.
            • nelox 11mo ago
              If only they were
  • metacritic12 11mo ago
    Given the lack of denial to the straightforward question, you're probably safe in reading this as "yes it was indeed AI generated".
• khazhoux 11mo ago
  So are we just disallowing multi-paragraph comments now?
  • mewpmewp2 11mo ago
    If it's fully AI generated, perhaps add a disclaimer to it?
    • minimaxir 11mo ago
      It is discouraged to post AI-generated comments to Hacker News, even if disclosed.
• altairprime 11mo ago
  If you think this comment was not written by the account holder or that account sales are occurring, please do as asked by the guidelines in such cases and contact the mods to report that, instead of posting about it in a discussion.
  • nelox 11mo ago
    Thank you
  • minimaxir 11mo ago
    Moderators already told OP to stop and OP did not stop. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46179328 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46179328
    • altairprime 11mo ago
      Irrelevant; “If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data.” and especially “Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead.” both apply.
  • mewpmewp2 11mo ago
    I wouldn't know if account sales was occurring, my first thought was that they sincerely wanted to have AI critique this article and post here. I don't think it is a good enough reason for me personally to flag. I think if someone was trying to use AI to farm they wouldn't post these types of critiques, but something safer rather. But I did wanted to see what their reasoning for posting those AI critiques was, and they answered, so I got my curiousity satisifed to an extent.
• deleted 11mo ago
  [deleted]