3 ms·
I like these, but it doesn't really work this time. The problem is that their idea won't work. "emotions" is too small a search space. A spam bot could just
by jrockway 14y ago
I like these, but it doesn't really work this time.
The problem is that their idea won't work. "emotions" is too small a search space. A spam bot could just answer "terrible" to every question and still send a good amount of spam.
reCaptcha works because there are a lot of words in English and a lot of source material that needs to be digitized. That makes it infesible to guess one word, let alone two words at the same time.
This emot-i-captcha requires a human to come up with an unbounded number of unique questions and answers, which is impossible.
- dlss 14y agoI think the bigger problem is that the questions are currently in plain text, which, since they require a human to write and once solved are solved forever, makes the approach as implemented a sort of quixotic reverse captcha. If they switch to image based questions, the potential problems for human solvers are magnified.
- anthonyb 14y agoNo it doesn't. Choose three words, one each from a group of positive (I like), neutral and negative (I don't like), along with something from a big list of news items which are good or bad. Now they have to choose (I like + good news) or (I don't like + bad news). Adding new words or new news items are independent of each other, and it doesn't seem that hard compared to traditional captchas.