7 ms·
Hmm, I go on holiday for 2 weeks and this is what I come back to? I obviously cannot go on holiday again, otherwise HN will be full of pictures of cute cats whe
by swombat 18y ago
Hmm, I go on holiday for 2 weeks and this is what I come back to? I obviously cannot go on holiday again, otherwise HN will be full of pictures of cute cats when I get back.
As others have pointed out, this video is pure trash. I would encourage others to flag it and get it removed from the front page, where it has no place or value other than the handful of comments that debunk it (though, sadly, I'm sure they'll soon be followed by countless angry replies trying to argue with the debunkings on some emotional "bankers are evil" basis).
- davidw 18y agopg has been actively discouraging 'this is off topic' posts. He says that they won't get upvotes or comments: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=460096 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=460096 By that logic, either net.kook conspiracy theories are on topic, or something hasn't worked quite according to plan.
- swombat 18y agoYeah, I know, he told me off for it too, but I can't resist... When I see trash, I have to call it trash.
- wheels 18y agoThat assumes that upvoting and flagging are a reasonable feedback loop for on-topic-ness. They aren't. Most stuff that's either on or off topic doesn't get upvoted, so there's not much data there for positive reinforcement to establish norms. If you look at the "new" page, most of it is on-topic at any given time and most of it will never see the front page. Flamboyant titles probably help set things out from the pack, but don't improve the quality of the site. I see meta-threads like this as the commit-list-flames of the OSS-world. You screw up the repository, and the crotchety regulars tell you how and why. This both educates and triggers social cohesion-fu, which maintains some level of quality. If we imaged, for instance, that we were to remove those flames from the OSS world, and suddenly, shitty code would be silently disappeared by the invisible hand of coding goodness, I don't suspect that would be nearly as effective. People would keep committing bad code. Turns out telling them why their code is bad teaches them to write better code.
- biohacker42 18y agoI flagged it, but I felt bad doing it. The video is PURE TRASH, and I know that because I was raised by economists. But I strongly suspect it is not at all obviously pure trash to a lay person. That's what's so worrying about articles like that, they are not obviously crap to a majority of people.
- axod 18y agoPlease... for the people who watched the video, please instead of saying it's "PURE TRASH", could you cite a few parts of the video that are factually incorrect?
- biohacker42 18y agoIt's been a long time since I managed to sit through that whole video when it first appeared on reddit. Right of the top of my head I can point out that the video contradicts itself. It claims both that A: The money supply is constantly being inflated (that's correct) And B: That interest guarantees some borrowers MUST go broke. (that's wrong, we just agreed the money supply is constantly being inflated.) For more discussions: http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=2959709 http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=295...
- swombat 18y agoThe last post on that thread is an excellent and very thorough blow-by-blow debunking of this trashy "documentary".
- jganetsk 18y agoThat the amount of debt in the world grows unchecked. The video did not do a great job of explaining what happens when debt is repaid. Let's say that the amount of bank-created money is defined as the total amount of money in everyone's account, minus the total amount in the bank's vaults. When one makes a payment on a loan, the payment is always part interest and part principal. The latter is dropped into the vault, and does not appear in anyone's account. So, this actually constitutes a removal of bank-created money from the system. The interest becomes revenue for the bank; the bank is a business and it should make money just like any other business. That revenue is used to pay the bank's operating expenses, dividends to the shareholders, and interest to all the depositors. So, it's not constantly accumulating in the hands of a wealthy few. And that brings up another important point that the video neglected to mention. Debt may increase exponentially, but so do savings. The other important detail left out is that payments are made with government-created money. Banks cannot print paper money... only the government. So the money in your wallet was not created by the bank. When your ATM served that money, the bank had to provide real cash. When you write a check, the bank has to transfer real money (entries on the Fed reserve's books) to the other bank. However, there are systems in place to reduce the amount of government-created money necessary (intra-bank transfers don't require any at all... inter-bank transfers are aggregated and canceled out where possible). So, the payments you make paying off your mortgage happen with government-created money, and do decrease the total amount of money and debt in the system.