2 ms·

I haven't seen your original comment but "It could work if they did it better" is in general a low value comment.

• johnfn 11mo ago
  You should go read it and see if you can tell me a way I could improve it. I felt I gave actionable advice, but I’m always happy to know if I could have said things better.
  • jayd16 11mo ago
    Looking at the comment, I would argue that it's fairly vague. Maybe it's clear if you have done it but not clear to others type thing. Then you undercut the advice by adding "I've always wondered if <confident suggestion> would work", making it unclear how much of the advice is a shot in the dark and how much you've actually seen results from that advice. Claims like "you might even one shot it" also make it seem like simple hype and not the war story of someone who's actually taken the advice. But you know, people are down voting me for engaging with your question as well so I don't know. Maybe it's all bots these days :p
    • johnfn 11mo ago
      Haha. For what it’s worth, and despite the downvotes, I do appreciate the feedback.
  • kcatskcolbdi 11mo ago
    You could improve it by simply doing the thing you describe and linking to it.