3 ms·
Maybe my comment was poorly worded. I'm not legitimately asking why we ever used gold. I agree it makes far more sense than helium or land when traded directl
by dpark 14y ago
Maybe my comment was poorly worded. I'm not legitimately asking why we ever used gold. I agree it makes far more sense than helium or land when traded directly. Once we moved to a paper currency, though, very little of that really mattered anymore. No one cares that oil is bulky when they trade it, because at worst they're moving around pieces of paper (more typically just bits in a system).
My real question is why gold should back our currency now. How does it make sense in a modern economy? We've divorced our currency from any one commodity, and I think that's a very good thing, because it helps to protect us from changes in the price of commodities.
- grecy 14y ago> My real question is why gold should back our currency now. How does it make sense in a modern economy? I've always wondered this: Without gold (or something) backing a currency, what stops the printing of trillions and trillions, aggressively devaluing the currency out there?
- dpark 14y agoTechnically? Nothing. Practically? The inability to sell credit if this kind of policy is pursued. No one is interested in dollars if they have no value. What stops you from maxing out all the credit you can get and then walking away? Same basic situation. Nothing stops you, but you'll likely end up bankrupt and regardless you'll have a hard time getting credit again.
- grecy 14y agoI ask because that's my basic understanding of what happened in the aftermath of the 2008 crash in the US. It seems trillions of dollars were printed with very little negative impact. How can that be?
- dpark 14y agoI don't fully know. To some extent it did have an impact, as some creditor nations stated publicly that our policies were affecting their decisions about buying future American debt. One of the ratings agencies also dropped our rating slightly (though that was a partisan farce). I think a lot of the impact was reduced by the fact that the money supply is already very large, and also by the fact that much of the new money didn't really enter the public currency supply. e.g. Buying a block of bad mortgages from a bank probably doesn't affect much. The bank was already treating this as a real asset, borrowing against it, etc.