6 ms·
tldr; The gold standard won't come back because the government would not be able to print trillions of fictional dollars whenever they want.
by grecy 14y ago
tldr; The gold standard won't come back because the government would not be able to print trillions of fictional dollars whenever they want.
- fusiongyro 14y agoThat's not untrue, but that way of looking at things ignores the fact that constant, wild fluctuations in the value of currency have negative consequences for everyone that depends on the currency.
- dpark 14y agoI also don't understand why gold-standard advocates seem to believe that gold is intrinsically the foundation of wealth. Why should the dollar be pegged to gold and not silver, or platinum, or rhodium? How about crude oil, or helium, or drinking water, or land in Manhattan? How about anything else that has value? All wealth is not gold, and I don't see a compelling reason why we should pretend that it is. All the things we value vary over time relative to each other. Given that, why should we arbitrarily pick one and say that it is the foundation of our currency? Why should the price of bread fluctuate wildly to accommodate gold speculators?
- fusiongyro 14y agoStrangely, we used to have a system based on "bimetalism," the idea that the currency is pegged to a certain quantity of gold and pegged to a certain quantity of silver simultaneously. Now it sounds like adding epicycles.
- danielweber 14y agoAnd the gymnastics that you have to go through to stop people from performing arbitrage on the stated ratio of gold:silver versus the market rate is also hilarious.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoGold was used because it's: 1) relatively hard to counterfeit 2) scarce enough that carrying enough in your pocket to equate to significant value is convenient 3) Durable 4) Fungible 5) The supply generally expanded at a slow and predictable rate (this wasn't always the case -- the Spanish conquests, e.g., set off a devastating round of inflation when all that gold got shipped back home). Silver and copper were also widely used. Platinum-group metals would work, but weren't widely known to the ancients. Crude oil: bulky and volatile. Helium: same as crude oil, but even more so (you'd need to haul around pressure tanks) Land: not portable. Not easily fungible. Drinking water: bulky. Gold was a pragmatic choice. In some of James Blish's SF stories, they used semiconductor-grade metals.
- dpark 14y agoMaybe my comment was poorly worded. I'm not legitimately asking why we ever used gold. I agree it makes far more sense than helium or land when traded directly. Once we moved to a paper currency, though, very little of that really mattered anymore. No one cares that oil is bulky when they trade it, because at worst they're moving around pieces of paper (more typically just bits in a system). My real question is why gold should back our currency now. How does it make sense in a modern economy? We've divorced our currency from any one commodity, and I think that's a very good thing, because it helps to protect us from changes in the price of commodities.
- grecy 14y ago> My real question is why gold should back our currency now. How does it make sense in a modern economy? I've always wondered this: Without gold (or something) backing a currency, what stops the printing of trillions and trillions, aggressively devaluing the currency out there?
- dpark 14y agoTechnically? Nothing. Practically? The inability to sell credit if this kind of policy is pursued. No one is interested in dollars if they have no value. What stops you from maxing out all the credit you can get and then walking away? Same basic situation. Nothing stops you, but you'll likely end up bankrupt and regardless you'll have a hard time getting credit again.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoYes, but most would argue that switching to a gold standard would make increase the amount of fluctuation rather than lessen it.
- grecy 14y ago> that way of looking at things ignores the fact that constant, wild fluctuations in the value of currency Yup, the best kind of gambling the kind where you rig the game so you always win. There's nothing worse than pesky fluctuations to impede constant winning. Next thing we'll change the free market to guarantee goods can always be sold for a certain price, irrelevant of demand.. oh hang on.
- fusiongyro 14y agoMaybe we should try a currency based on something you have in abundance: straw men.
- joshmaker 14y agoA poll of American economists a while back found 0% in favor of returning to the gold standard: http://www.igmchicago.org/igm-economic-experts-panel/poll-results?SurveyID=SV_cw1nNUYOXSAKwrq http://www.igmchicago.org/igm-economic-experts-panel/poll-re...
- calciphus 14y agoIt also means that the majority of our currency would be controlled by people outside our country, prospecting on its future value. If that doesn't terrify you, it should.
- grecy 14y agoI'm not in your country. My country does not live in fear. I'm not terrified.
- tzs 14y agoI can use those "fictional" dollars to buy things, so the word "fictional" must be being used in that sentence with a meaning I'm unfamiliar with.
- grecy 14y agoFictional in the sense that I work my whole life and have say $500k. Someones else works their whole life and has say $750k. Some banks make some bad decisions, lose a bunch of money, then go and print a few trillion dollars so they come out ahead. These dollars we speak of truly must be fictional if some people have to work their entire lives to get 500 000 of them, while others can just "make" trillions on a whim to avoid having negative dollars.
- arohner 14y agoWhile true, it's worth pointing out the Romans devalued their silver coins. One day they woke up and said "The denarian will now contain X grams of silver, rather than X+N grams. Oh and btw, all those contracts we wrote that said we'd pay you 100 coins, yeah, you're getting paid in the new denomination".